Clicky

Apple Crisp Vs. Apple Pie

Apple Crisp vs Apple Pie: What’s the Difference?

Last Updated on June 21, 2024 by Lori Walker

With fall upon us, some sweets just scream the spirit of the season, especially those with apples. Apple crisp and apple pie stand out as two top picks that truly capture this magical time.

While both feature sweet, tender apples and a buttery, crispy topping, some key differences set them apart. 

So what’s the difference between apple crisp and apple pie? Read on to find out.

Main Differences Between Apple Crisp & Apple Pie

Apple Crisp on a Plate
  1. Topping: The topping is the most apparent difference between apple crisp and apple pie. Apple pie typically has a flaky crust on the bottom and the top, while apple crisp has a streusel-like topping made from oats, flour, butter, and sugar.
  2. Texture: Apple pie has a soft, flaky crust on the bottom and top, while the filling is usually soft and tender due to being baked for a longer time. On the other hand, Apple crisp has a crunchy, crumbly topping and a firmer texture in the apple filling.
  3. Baking Time: Apple pie is typically baked for a longer time, usually around an hour, while apple crisp is baked for a shorter time, usually around 30-40 minutes. This is because apple pie needs more time to cook the filling and crust thoroughly, while apple crisp doesn’t need as much time as the topping browns quickly.
  4. Preparation: Apple pie can be more labor-intensive than apple crisp because it requires making a crust and a filling separately, whereas apple crisp only requires mixing the topping and slicing the apples.
  5. Serving: Apple pie is typically served in slices, while apple crisp can be served in individual ramekins or a large baking dish that can be spooned into servings.
  6. Calories: Apple pie is generally considered higher in calories than apple crisp due to the double crust and potential use of butter in the filling. Apple crisp typically uses less butter and sugar, making it a lighter option.
  7. Variations: While apple pie is typically made with just apples and a few spices, apple crisp can be more versatile and include other fruits or nuts in the topping, such as cranberries or pecans.

Find out how long pecan pie will last in the fridge here.

Which Dish Is Healthier?

In terms of nutrition, apple crisp [1], and apple pie can be part of a healthy diet when consumed in moderation. Both dishes contain apples, which are high in fiber and nutrients and offer health benefits such as improved digestion and reduced inflammation. 

“Dad was a baker, and we lived above the bakery, so I was always popping down to have an apple pie or a doughnut or a custard or gypsy tart: I had a very sweet tooth, and I think that that was what got me into doing what I do now.”

– Paul Hollywood, Celebrity Chef

However, the added sugar and butter in the topping and crust can add significant calories, making both dishes higher in sugar and fat. 

If you want to make a slightly healthier version, you can reduce the amount of sugar or use alternative sweeteners like honey or maple syrup. 

Opting for a lighter topping with less butter and more oats in apple crisp or a single crust in apple pie can also reduce the calorie count.

But what causes my apple pie to be watery?

Which Dish Is Better For A Crowd?

Sliced of Apple Pie on a Plate

When serving a crowd, apple crisp is generally considered the better option. This is because apple crisps can be made in larger quantities and served in individual ramekins or in a large baking dish that can be spooned into servings. 

Additionally, apple crisp doesn’t require slicing or plating, making it easy to serve and clean up. On the other hand, apple pie can be a little more challenging to serve, as it requires cutting into slices and serving on plates or bowls. 

This can be time-consuming and may require more effort from the host. If you’re looking to serve a crowd, apple crisp is a convenient and delicious option that will please everyone.

You might also like to read about how long key lime pie last here.

Which Dish Is More Versatile?

Regarding versatility, apple crisp is generally considered more adaptable than apple pie. While apple pie is typically made with just apples and a few spices, apple crisp can be more versatile and include other fruits or nuts in the topping, such as cranberries or pecans. 

Additionally, to make each dish your own, you can experiment with different spices and flavors in the topping, such as cinnamon, nutmeg, or vanilla extract. 

“Apple crisp and apple pie, both kissed by cinnamon winds, present a choice between nostalgia’s embrace and a crunchy adventure. It’s a tug-of-war between layers of flaky tales and caramelized whispers, reminding us that in every bite, the seasons of the orchard dance on our taste buds.”

Leonelli Bakery

Apple crisp can also be served with various toppings or accompaniments, such as a scoop of vanilla ice cream, whipped cream [2], or a dollop of Greek yogurt. 

On the other hand, apple pie is typically served as is, with no added toppings or accompaniments. If you’re looking for a dessert customized to your tastes and preferences, apple crisp is the more versatile.

Related Post: 5 Simple Ways To Save A Soggy Pie After Baking

FAQs

What apples are best for pie or apple crisp?

The best apples for a pie or apple crisp hold their shape and texture when baked. Tart and firm apples, such as Granny Smith, Honeycrisp, or Braeburn, are ideal for both dishes as they won’t turn mush when cooked. 

However, some prefer mixing different apple varieties to create a more complex flavor profile.

But how long will canned apple butter last?

What is the difference between a crisp cobbler and a pie?

The main difference between a crisp cobbler and a pie is the type of topping used. Crisps have a crumbly streusel-like topping made from flour, sugar, and butter, while cobblers have a biscuit-like topping made from flour, butter, and milk or cream. 

Pies, on the other hand, have a double crust made from pastry dough. The filling for all three desserts can be similar, typically consisting of fruit, sugar, and spices, but the texture and taste of the dessert can vary significantly based on the type of topping used.

Find out how you can prevent the pecan pie from leaking through the crust here.

Final Thoughts

Both apple crisp and apple pie are delicious fall desserts that offer a satisfying taste of autumn. While they share some similarities, such as the use of sweet, tender apples and warming spices, they are typical dishes with unique characteristics. 

Apple pie features a flaky crust on the bottom and top, while apple crisp has a crunchy, crumbly topping made from oats, flour, butter, and sugar. 

Apple crisp is easier and quicker to prepare, making it an excellent option for those looking to whip up a delicious dessert without too much fuss. On the other hand, apple pie has a classic comfort that can’t be beaten. 

Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on preference for texture, flavor, and preparation time. Regardless of your choice, both dishes will impress your family and friends this fall.

References:

  1. https://www.allrecipes.com/article/best-apples-for-apple-pie-and-apple-crisp/
  2. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/18352/whipped-cream/
Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *