Clicky

Best Boston Cream Pie

10 Best Boston Cream Pies Tasted & Ranked (Updated)

Last Updated on February 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

This sweet treat is typically crafted using a combination of pastry cream, chocolate ganache, and the most delicate vanilla sponge cake you’ve ever experienced.

That’s right – we’re talking about Boston cream pies.

If you want to know where to go for the best Boston cream pie, our team took the liberty of researching and trying some places out.  

Top 10 Best Boston Cream Pies You Should Try in Boston

Close Up Shot of Boston Cream Pie

10. Veggie Galaxy 

Do not forget to visit Veggie Galaxy when you are near the area and try some of their classic American cuisines with contemporary twists. 

They are just around Central  Square, Cambridge, Massachusetts Avenue, operating seven days a week.

They serve their weekly specials, and they have various selections to choose from. Of course, don’t forget to try their Boston Cream Pies, made with 100% vegan ingredients. 

9. The Ritz 

If you’ve checked in at The Ritz-Carlton Hotel and Resort in Boston, Massachusetts, you should at least dine and try the various delicacies served at Artisan Bistro. 

It’s well known for its amazing and classic American cuisine with a Bistro-inspired twist. Indulge in their savory dishes and baked goodies like the traditional cream pies in Bistro-style. 

8. Legal Harborside 

If you want freshly baked cream pies, get some from Legal Harborside, located at 270 North Avenue, Boston, MA. 

They serve fresh from the market seafood along with other side dishes and desserts like your favorite classic American dessert, cream pie. 

Reserve a seat and savor the moment while enjoying the fresh seafood and cuisines at Legal Harborside. 

7. Union Oyster House 

Dine in at Union Oyster House, located at 41 Union Street, Boston, MA. It’s one of the oldest restaurants in America and is well known for its extraordinary cuisine. 

There are a lot of seafood dishes for you to try, and you can finish off with the classic cream pie.

6. Bova’s Bakery

The next stop is Bova’s Bakery, located at 134 Salem Street, Boston, Massachusetts. 

It has 4.5 stars and is one of the best-reviewed bakeries that serve your all-time favorite pastries, sweets, and desserts.

Of course, their cream pies are on top of their selections. Aside from that, Bova’s Bakery also offers a variety of Italian specialties and other baked goodies.

5. Union Square Donuts 

Wanna grab some coffee? Visit Union Square Donuts at 100 Hanover Street, Boston, Massachusetts, and enjoy your favorite pastry with coffee.  

Union Square Donuts serves the best donuts and other pastries in town, including cream pies. They also have other branches in Sommevile and Brooklyn.

Read: Does My Cafe Need A Grease Trap?

4. Mike’s Pastry 

Continue your cream pie food taste adventure at Mike’s Pastry. It is located at 300 Hanover Street, Boston, Massachusetts, just minutes from Union Square Donuts. 

Mike’s Pastry is well known for being the home of one-of-a-kind cannoli. They also serve other pastries, cookies, cakes, and of course, cream pies.

3. Flour Bakery & Cafe

Grab some snacks and indulge in the tasty pastries, salads, and sandwiches at Flour Bakery & Cafe at South End, Washington Street in Boston. 

Indulge in the all-time classic favorites – apple pie and cream pie. Aside from that, you can also shop for some baking tools and products like cookbooks, cookie dough boxes, and baking sets.

2. Modern Pastry 

Modern Pastry Shop caters to the cravings of those with a sweet tooth. 

They are located around 257 & 263 Hanover Street in Boston and serve various cake selections, including European and American cakes, cheesecakes, pies, and tarts.

You can also take home treats like macarons, biscotti, pizzelle, and torrone.

Read: 10 Things You Can Do With Leftover Pastry Cream

1. Omni Parker House

Lastly is the Omni Parker House, in the heart of downtown Boston, Massachusetts. Omni Parker House Hotels and Resorts is one of America’s iconic restaurants and whiskey bars.

“I’d say about 80% of the people that order dessert are the Boston Cream Pie. It’s creamy, silky, smooth, and chocolatey. Heaven!” 

– Gerard Tice, Executive Chef, Omni Park House Hotel

They also serve famous and classic cuisines and dishes that are surely palatable. 

If you plan to check in here, don’t miss its version of the classic American cream pie, one of the best in Boston [1].

Find out how many calories are in an oatmeal cream pie here.

Our Favorite Boston Cream Pie Recipe 

Boston Crem Pie

Prep Time:

Approximately 30 to 40 minutes. 

Total Time: 

Its total time before serving is around 5 hours and 10 minutes (including prep and baking time).

Ingredients:

Cake:

  • 1 ¼ cups all-purpose flour
  • ⅓ cup shortening
  • ¾ cup whole milk
  • 1 ½ teaspoons Baking Powder
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • 1 egg
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Filling:

  • ⅛ teaspoon salt
  • ⅓ cup white sugar
  • 1 ½ cups milk
  • 2 tablespoons cornstarch
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 2 egg yolks

Glaze:

  • 3 tablespoons butter
  • 2 (1 oz) squares unsweetened chocolate
  • ¾ teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1 cup confectioners’ sugar
  • 2 tablespoons hot water

Instructions:

  1. Make the pastry cream first by mixing the sugar, egg yolks, milk, butter, vanilla, and cornstarch on a stove until it’s nice, smooth, and thickened. Refrigerate afterward.
  2. Then, make the vanilla sponge cake layers and layer them together with pastry cream.
  3. Top it off with a chocolate ganache. 

Serving:

At most, 12 servings.

Read: What’s The Difference Between Scooter Pie & Moon Pie?

FAQs

Should you refrigerate Boston cream pie?

Refrigerating the Boston cream pie is highly recommended since it might perish easily when left at room temperature for over an hour. 

Otherwise, the pastry cream would be unable to support the ganache, and it would not be as presentable when cut and served. But should Boston Cream Donuts be kept in the fridge?

What’s a Boston cream pie?

A Boston cream pie is unlike the traditional pie since it combines a butter cake layer with vanilla custard and is glazed with chocolate ganache or icing [2]. 

It resembles the cake you bake at home or buys in a bakery rather than pie.

Why is Boston cream pie so good?

Its soft, buttery, moist texture and balanced taste make a Boston cream pie so good that it became a famous and classic dessert in the US. 

Additionally, the unique ingredients being used and combination twists make it stand out among other pies. 

Final Words

This classic cream pie is one of the all-time favorite pies of Americans, next to apple pie. 

If you visit Boston, make sure to try some of its unique versions from the top bakeries and restaurants mentioned above.

The next time you’re craving sweets after dinner, try out a Boston cream pie (if you haven’t yet), as this may just be your new favorite pie.

References:

  1. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/a-slice-of-heaven-boston-cream-pie/
  2. https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/boston-cream-pie-chocolate
Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *