Best Cookie Storage Containers

10 Best Cookie Storage Containers To Keep Baked Treats Fresh

Last Updated on June 21, 2024 by Lori Walker

No matter if you like store-bought cookies or ones baked at home, **a solid cookie jar** is key to keeping your treats fresh and tasty.

Whether you’re a dessert lover or into baking, cookie jars are a staple kitchen arsenal to store treats for later.

That said, we’ve rounded up the best cookie storage containers for easy access and to aesthetically keep your treats fresh.

Top 10 Cookie Storage Containers You Should Try

1. OXO Good Grips POP Container

Man Holding OXO Good Grips POP Container

Capacity: 5.6 liters

Material: Plastic

Average Price: $20.88

Why We Like It:

The OXO Good Grips is the best cookie storage container as it activates its airtight seal with a button push.

It has an A-lid type compatible with scoops and labels. Moreover, it has a wide mouth, so you can conveniently fill it with sugar, flour, and snacks.

This dishwasher-safe container is stackable and perfect for maximizing storage space.

2. Anchor Hocking Heritage Hill Jar

Anchor Hocking Heritage Hill Jar Glass Container

Capacity: 3.8 liters

Material: Glass

Average Price: $29.46

Why We Like It:

Invented by John Landis Mason, glass jars are the perfect storage to keep your freshly baked cookies [1].

If you’re in search of an aesthetically pleasing cookie jar, the Anchor Hocking Heritage Hill Jar is perfect for a busy kitchen, boasting durable and thick-walled.

Its key features include an all-clear glass cookie jar with oversized knobs and lead-free and BPA-free materials.

3. Snapware Snap ‘N Stack 2-Layer Container

Woman Holding Snapware Snap ‘N Stack 2-Layer Container

Capacity: 1 liter

Material: Plastic

Average Price: $10.79

Why We Like It:

If you’re looking for a multi-purpose food storage container, this one from Snapware will not disappoint. 

It’s a portable storage container that comes with two layers. Also, it’s one of the best containers for beautifully decorated cookies, as you can store them in a single layer.

This BPA-free plastic container includes a dessert carrier with stackable trays and egg holders that are freezer, microwave, and dishwasher-safe.

4. Lock & Lock Easy Essentials Food Lids (Budget Pick)

Lock & Lock Food Container

Capacity: 2 to 3 ounces

Material: Plastic

Average Price: $26.67

Why We Like It:

Besides glass containers, keeping cookies fresh longer is more possible if you use Lock & Lock with airtight lids.

Save space and money with Lock & Lock containers as you can stack them up, and has a rubber seal to prevent leaks and spills. 

This BPA-free plastic container is famous for its airtight lid and proven durability, perfect for long-term use.

5. Rubbermaid Leak-Proof Brilliance Food Storage Set 

Rubbermaid Leak-Proof Brilliance Container

Capacity: 1.3 to 3.2 cups

Material: Plastic

Average Price: $14.99

Why We Like It:

But if you’re not a fan of glass cookie containers, this food storage set from Rubbermaid is another great option for an airtight lid.

Store homemade cookies with this leak-proof food container featuring a BPA-free Tritan lid, secure latches, and an airtight seal.

Also, these crystal clear containers are stackable and safe for the freezer, microwave, and dishwasher.

6. Juvale Nesting Cookie Tin Set

Capacity: Small, Medium, and Large sizes

Material: Tin

Average Price: $20.99

Why We Like It:

The Juvale Nesting Cookie Tin Set is the perfect canister if you’re planning to bake a fresh batch of cookies for holidays or special occasions.

Drop cookies to your loved ones in style with this stylish canister set, made from sturdy yet lightweight tin material.

It comes in three sizes, and the small container measures around 3 inches thick. Check out these non-toxic cookie sheets here.

7. DII Kitchen Accessories Collection Ceramics Cookie Jar

Capacity: 1.1 liters

Material: Ceramic

Average Price: $30.42

Why We Like It:

Another best cookie storage container, the DII Kitchen ceramic jars are a must-have for vintage lovers.

This classic cookie jar is perfect for gifts or to add a simple yet sophisticated vibe to the kitchen.

Ensure your cookies stay fresh since their lid has a silicone gasket for an airtight seal. Also, hand-wash only the cookie jar to maintain the glazed finish.

8. Ziploc Freezer Gallon Bags

Man Holding Ziploc Freezer Gallon Bags

Capacity: 150 liters

Material: Plastic

Average Price: $10.50 (60 pieces)

Why We Like It:

Aside from cookie jars, the Ziploc Freezer Gallon Bags would make a great storage container for your goodies. 

It features a trip seal system and Grip ‘n Seal technology with a double zipper for convenience and to ensure air is kept out.

The Ziploc bags are made of BPA-free plastic and are freezer, microwave, and fridge safe, so you can use these bags to store cookie dough in the freezer.

“To keep your cookies fresh, you need to keep air out.”

– Katie Bandurski, Senior Shopping Editor, Taste of Home

Find out how you can make churros without a pastry bag here.

9. Ankou Food Airtight Container

Ankou Food Airtight Container on a Shelves

Capacity: 380 ml

Material: Acrylonitrile styrene resin

Average Price: $24.99

Why We Like It:

To preserve food and prevent its spoilage, this canister from Ankou is another great alternative to a cookie jar [2].

It’s an airtight, stackable canister that perfectly fits the lid and doesn’t leak even if you turn it upside down.

In addition, Ankou features a pop-up design that opens and closes with just a one-button press.

10. Kook Glass Canister

Capacity: 2.27 liters

Material: Glass

Average Price: $29.95

Why We Like It:

This adorable jar from Kook is another kitchen staple, perfect for keeping cookies, pasta, and other sweet treats.

Kook glass jar has a rubber ring on the lid that helps create a tight seal around the jar’s mouth.

It’s a clear durable glass jar that you can use for other purposes, from preserving food to organizing your bathroom vanity.



What is the best material for a cookie jar?

If you’re getting a cookie jar, the best material you should look for is one made of glass. It’s a classic yet sophisticated cookie jar that lets you clearly see your goodie’s condition.

Find out the best edible markers for cookies here.

What is the best way to store cookies to keep them fresh?

Before you keep your baked goodies in cookie jars, ensure it has already cooled down. Keep them at room temperature using an airtight canister or jar with rubber rings on the lid.

But what is the best way to keep Crumbl Cookies fresh?

Are tins good for storing cookies?

Yes, they are. It helps maintain the cookie’s firmness more than plastic canisters. However, using airtight canisters for chewy cookies is best to preserve your treats longer.

Check out these easy ways to keep pancake mix for a long time here.

In Conclusion

Through this guide to the best cookie jars, we hope you’ve found the perfect canister based on your storage needs.

Nevertheless, while the key features of these canisters differ from one another, they can surely keep cookies fresh longer.

On the other hand, it’s essential to double-check for molds before consuming your treats, even if they’re tightly sealed.

Lastly, don’t forget to label them with a date, so you can remember until when they’re good for consumption.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *