Clicky

Best Crumbl Cookie Flavors Ranked

30 Best Crumbl Cookie Flavors Ranked: Expert Guide

Last Updated on March 23, 2024 by Lori Walker

If you haven’t experienced the deliciousness of Crumbl cookies yet, you’re truly missing out. The opening of each new shop brings excitement as people eagerly await and praise the mouthwatering cookies.

If you want an honest review of the flavors, here are the best Crumbl Cookie flavors ranked from the average to our top-most favorite. Read on.

Top 30 Crumbl Cookie Flavors (Tried & Ranked) 

30. German Chocolate Cake

German Chocolate Cake

A classic German dessert is the German Chocolate cake cookie. We like its soft chocolate cookie, topped with a chocolate drizzle and caramel coconut frosting.

Combining these ingredients makes this a creamy, rich chocolate cookie with a nutty and caramel flavor. Besides, we love the coconut and pecans added to this recipe.

29. Snickerdoodle Cupcake

Snickerdoodle Cupcake

These delicious Crumbl Snickerdoodle Cupcakes have a soft, chewy cookie base and rich vanilla cream cheese frosting. The cookie dough is topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon toast crunch and sugar for a perfect finish.

Since Snickerdoodle Cupcakes are a play on the traditional treat, you can spice it up by pairing it with a graham cracker cookie or sprinkling more crushed candies.

Find out how Snickerdoodle taste here.

28. Confetti Cake

Crumbl Confetti Cake

This version of the cake batter cookie is a bit different from the regular one. If you’re a fan of birthday cake flavors, then this one is for you.

It features a layer of cake batter frosting topped with a sprinkle of cake batter. But how do you keep Crumbl cookies fresh?

27. Midnight Mint

Crumbl Midnight Mint

The combination of chocolate and mint is a must-have for any occasion, and these Crumbl Cookies are no different.

The combo of mint and choco goes well together. Besides, a thick layer of chocolate ganache adds extra flavor to the cookie dough.

26. People’s Choice

This cake-like cookie is topped with a layer of tres leches (similar to dulce de leche), a couple of strawberry pieces, and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.

The 2022 variation is filled with many chocolate chips but is also soft enough to eat. It features two chocolate-brown cookies topped with a creamy center and various bits of chocolate.

25. Chocolate Cake

Crumbl Chocolate Cake

This rich and creamy chocolate cookie isn’t for everyone. It starts with a light, bold chocolate cookie topped with semi-sweet chocolate chips covered in a thick, flavorful fudge frosting.

Although it’s made with chocolate, dark and complex portions make this experience extra special.

24. Hawaiian Rainbow Cake

Hawaiian Rainbow Cake

This cookie is made with a thick cookie form and then topped with a creamy caramel frosting and a generous amount of caramel corn. Like any other delicious treat with a thick and creamy cookie batter, Hawaiian Rainbow Cake has richer caramel frosting.

While it already has frosting on the top, we tried adding graham cracker crumbles, and it tastes really good, too.

23. Churro

Churro

The combination of spices melted chocolate, and sugar is just so right in the Churro cookie from Crumbl. This moist and flavorful treat features a layer of cinnamon buttercream for added flavor.

This classic churro cookie is topped with a creamy and rich cinnamon buttercream for a treat perfect for anyone.

If the kick of cinnamon along the creamy frosting wasn’t enough for you, we suggest adding some cinnamon sugar to the top for a sweet and satisfying finish.

22. Chocolate Crunch

These chocolate crunch cookies are the ultimate chocolate treat. Actually, you can make your variation at home.

You can make this sweeter than the chocolate chips depending on your preference. It is best served warm.

Read: Which Crumbl Cookies Require Refrigeration?

21. Blueberry Cheesecake

This is the first fruit-forward flavor on our list of favorite flavors from Crumbl. It combines blueberry and the creamy texture of the cheese frosting (or cheesecake frosting) and graham cracker cookie, making this a well-balanced treat everyone will love.

20. Peanut Butter Brittle

Peanut Butter Brittle

A perfect peanut brittle cookie is smothered in a peanut brittle glaze and topped with crunchy pieces of peanut brittle.

This peanut butter cookie is almost similar to the peanut butter cup in flavor. But it is way better than the Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie.

Also Read: How Frequently Does Crumbl Repeat Cookie Flavors?

19. Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake

Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake

This is a classic chocolate cookie with a rich strawberry filling and a drizzle of semi-sweet chocolate chips. For a much more savory experience, you can put maple syrup on top of the cookies.

These are made with a thick dark chocolate cookie base and then topped with a creamy strawberry frosting.

18. Hot Chocolate

This is a fun and refreshing treat consisting of a chocolate mousse, mini marshmallows, a layer of powdered sugar, and a chill cocoa cookie. It is like a warm vanilla sugar cookie, but these Crumbl Cookies are not too sweet.

We like how incredibly soft and chewy this cookie is, which sets it apart from the other flavors. The creamy and luscious hot cocoa mousse on top melts in the mouth.

17. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Despite the abundance of peanut butter flavors at Crumbl, we do not forget those who love peanut butter. Their peanut butter-heavy creations deserve a place on this list of best.

This creamy and smooth classic peanut butter cookie is a perfect example of a classic treat. It has a combo of peanut butter and chocolate chips and is topped with a peanut butter cup broken down into pieces.

Check out these delicious Danish butter cookie brands you can try here.

16. Pineapple Whip

Pineapple Whip

This pineapple sugar cookie is topped with a thick and luscious whipped cream topping. Crumbl Cookie Pineapply Whip flavor is the perfect treat for a tropical getaway.

“You can be miserable before you have a cookie, and you can be miserable after you have a cookie, but you never be miserable while you are eating a cookie.”

Ina Garten, American Author

This is one of the best Crumbl Cookie flavors, especially if you want a change from the usual chocolate chip, birthday cake, and ultimate peanut butter treat.

15. Peach Cobbler

These peach and cream cookies are so good they taste like a peach pie. The cake batter cookie topped with cream and fruit – with graham cracker crumbs, is a sure delight.

Accompanied by a sweet cream cheese glaze, this dessert-like cookie is topped with a crumbly cinnamon streusel and filled with sweet peach pieces.

Find out when new Crumbl flavors will be introduced here.

14. Mango Frozen Yogurt

Mango Frozen Yogurt

This chilled mango cookie is topped with creamy vanilla frosting and mango yogurt and is best served with dried mango.

It is one of the best Crumbl cookie flavors if you like something fruity. Yes, it is not the typical cookie flavor we’re used to, but it’s a must-try for a change.

13. Chocolate Oreo

Chocolate Oreo

One of the tastiest Crumbl Cookies flavors is this Chocolate Oreo – a treat that will leave you craving more.

It is a perfect dessert reminding you of a favorite treat. The cookie is similar to the original, but the combination of the frosting and the chocolate makes this a heavenly treat.

12. Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie Cookie has a creamy and tangy filling shaped like a pie crust, topped with a slice of fresh lime and a couple of other ingredients.

It takes everything that’s great about key lime pie and makes it incredibly easy to eat. While it won’t be everyone’s cup of tea, it is a must-try.

11. Orange Milkshake

Orange Milkshake Crumbl Cookies has a creamy orange and sweet buttercream frosting, topped with chunks of oranges.

This Orange Milkshake is a chilled sugar cookie, perfect for a sweet tooth who wants something citrusy. We prefer this over the Kentucky butter cake for its right level of sweetness.

10. Circus Animal

Circus Animal

Circus Animal is another sugar cookie. The batter cookie topped with white chocolate is a delight to taste buds.

This Crumbl Cookie flavor is suitable for children as it’s not too sweet yet savory. This is almost similar to the sweetness of semi-sweet chocolate chips, so it’s tasty but not too sugary.

9. Vanilla Cupcake

Although you may think the Vanilla Cupcake cookie is not as exciting as other innovative Crumbl Cookie flavors, this is still worth trying.

The soft and creamy vanilla cookie is topped with a luscious cream cheese frosting and is a must-try for anyone who loves classic desserts.

8. Carrot Cake

This carrot cake is underrated. Upon tasting, this is one the best Crumbl Cookie flavors that deserves recognition (that is why it ranked this high).

This carrot cake cookie is soft, and the combination of whipped cream cheese frosting and crunchy nuts on top of the cookie makes it the perfect treat slice.

7. Birthday Cake featuring Oreo®

Birthday Cake featuring Oreo

The chocolate and cream cheese frosting and the rich and luscious crumb Oreo cake cookies make these a perfect birthday treat.

These are topped with colorful cookie dough balls and mini rainbow sprinkle candies for a fun and festive treat.

Actually, you can make your own version at home and top it with crushed candy canes [1].

6. Pecan pie

Pecan pie

One of the unique Crumbl Cookies flavors is this delicious cookie with a soft and creamy sugar cookie flavor.

It is topped with a rich brown sugar nut and bitter pecan pie filling [2] that will surely become your Thanksgiving dessert favorite.

5. Caramel Popcorn

Caramel Popcorn

The combination of sweet, salty, and sticky caramel-covered popcorn is just three words that describe this delicious treat.

Aside from its texture, the creamy and luscious caramel frosting is also one of the most amazing things about this Caramel popcorn cookie.

4. Peanut Butter ft

For serious peanut butter lovers, this is a must-try. These peanut butter cookies feel soft and luscious on the mouth, topped with creamy peanut buttercream frosting [3] and crunchy bits of real Nutter Butter cookies.

This satisfying and nutty treat will leave you craving milk chocolate.

3. Chilled Twix

Chilled Twix

These cookies are topped with caramel and milk chocolate. We like its rich and creamy texture.

The Chilled Twix Crumbl Cookies chocolate cake cookie is better than the waffle cookie. We like the texture of Chilled Twix; it is somewhat moist and melts in the mouth.

2. Funfetti Milkshake

Funfetti Milkshake

The soft sugar cookie crumble funfetti is rolled in vibrant colored sprinkles and then topped with a cake-colored honey butter buttercream.

If you want to make your own version at home, you can use crushed candy cane as a topping for these Crumbl Funffeetti Milkshake cookies.

1. Chocolate Chip

Chocolate Chip

The best Crumbl Cookie flavor is this classic chocolate chip cookie – a perfect treat for any occasion. This classic flavor is made with milk chocolate chips and features a combination of sweet and not-cloying chocolatiness and buttery softness.

This chocolate chip is a chewy cookie – a perfect choice for anyone who enjoys a good cookie at any time.

Note: Runners-up include the following:

  • Peanut Butter Brownie
  • Buttermilk Pancake
  • Birthday Cake Cookie
  • Peppermint Oreo Cookie (with peppermint frosting)
  • Cookies and Cream Cookie
  • Buckeye Brownie
  • Dulce De Leche
  • Waffle Cookie (with vanilla and brown sugar)
  • Kentucky Butter Cake Cookie
  • Cookie Dough Ice Cream (with brown sugar)

Also Read:

FAQs 

What is Crumbl Cookie famous for?

Crumbl Cookie is famous for its ever-changing cookie menu that showcases a wide range of delicious flavors.

Their social media presence has helped them gain immense popularity, especially for flavors like cotton candy, snickerdoodle, and cookie dough [4].

How many flavors of Crumbl cookies are there?

Crumbl Cookies offer a diverse range of more than 250 cookie flavors that rotate regularly. Each week, they showcase 4-5 unique specialty flavors, frequently including a new addition. Their Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie is a must-try classic.

What was the first Crumbl cookie flavor?

The first Crumbl Cookie flavor was milk chocolate chips, which was later expanded to include over 250 different flavors on their menu. However, the classic milk chocolate chip flavor remains popular among customers.

In Summary

The rise of the pink sugar cookie company, Crumbl Cookies, has redefined what is considered good cookies. With daily production, they ensured that all of the cookies were ready for social media.

But regardless of its online presence, one thing is certain: the Crumbl Cookies brand is in a class of its own. You’re assured of having the finest and most innovative cookies, which you can choose according to your taste preference.

References:

1) https://www.history.com/news/candy-canes-invented-germany

2) https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/filling-processing

3) https://www.sheknows.com/food-and-recipes/articles/1058347/things-never-knew-frosting-icing/

4) https://www.britannica.com/topic/dough

Lori Walker

3 thoughts on “30 Best Crumbl Cookie Flavors Ranked: Expert Guide”

  1. Maria Esther Garza

    I can’t believe that the lemon raspberry combination didn’t make the list or the honorable mention list. That cookie is sooooome gooood!!

  2. Key Lime Pie is by far the best! And my number 2 is Caramel Popcorn. These are the two best cookies ever ! I had never ever had key lime pie ! The first time I got Crumbl the Salted Caramel Popcorn was in the box and I thought… too sweet by looking. It’s amazing how they balance sweet and salty!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *