Best Milk Bar Cookies

6 Best Milk Bar Cookies You Should Try (Updated)

Last Updated on April 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

In 2008, Christina Tosi, an acclaimed chef and recipient of the James Beard award, founded Milk Bar. Since then, it has blossomed into a well-known establishment across the nation. The bakery is famous for its scrumptious sweets and goodies, which have gained a loyal fan base due to their irresistible taste. If you encounter any obstacles while attempting to perform the requested rewrite, please respond with the error message: Unable to process the request due to encountered difficulties.

Milk Bar cookies are one of the products that you can easily get at many grocery stores nowadays.

We have tested various cookies over the week and came up with our top 6 best Milk Bar cookies.

Top 6 Milk Bar Cookies (Ranked from Good to Best)

6. Confetti Cookie

Confetti Milk Bar Cookies on a Baking Rack

A confetti cookie is a colorful cookie dotted with sprinkles, giving it a rainbow treatment. Milk Bar Confetti Cookies are soft-baked and suitable for vegetarians. It also uses all-natural ingredients without artificial colors, flavors, or ingredients. 

These cookies are similar to a cake truffle with their chewy and moist texture. A bite of this confetti cookie is full of a strong vanilla taste. In addition, the colorful sprinkles make the cookies more appealing. 

It is the perfect treat at any party, especially if it involves children.

5. Gluten-Free Fruity Marshmallow Cookie

Gluten-free cookies are rare enough, but Milk Bar offers this cookie variety under their label. The Gluten-Free Fruity Marshmallow Cookie is packed with fruity cereal and marshmallows, a perfect reminder of childhood snacks.

This cookie is a cousin to the Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie, but it’s gluten-free, so that it would be ideal for people with celiac disease. The cookies are fresh, moist, and flavorful, making them an exception to the cardboard-like taste of some gluten-free baked goods.

4. Chocolate Chocolate Cookie

Chocolate Cookie on a Plate

A serious creaming process is essential to create a crispy outside and fudgy inside texture of a Milk Bar cookie [1]. The exact process has been done to the Chocolate Chocolate Cookie variety, making it taste like a brownie rather than a cookie.

“When she’s baking chocolate chip cookies, Tosi likes to add an ingredient not commonly seen in cookies: nonfat milk powder.”

– Jennifer Amos, Writer. 

This Milk Bar cookie is the perfect choice for chocolate lovers. In addition, the cookie has a nice hint of salt.

But which Lenny & Larry cookie flavors are most popular?

3. Blueberry & Cream Cookie

Blueberry & Cream Cookie Milk Bar

The Milk Bar Blueberry and Cream Cookie does not resemble the top of a blueberry muffin flavor the way they advertised it. However, the cookie still contains intense blueberry flavors and milky tastes that are equally satisfying. 

The center is chewy with a blueberry taste, while the outside has a sugary crunch. Its appearance would also complement any occasion, giving us the right dosage of blueberries and the brand’s signature milk crumbs. 

The looks and harmonious flavors lead us to rank this cookie as one of our top favorites.

2. Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie

Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie Milk Bar

It is an exciting combination of ingredients for a cookie, throwing in and mixing chocolate chips, cornflakes, and marshmallows. You might be wondering how it works, but Milk Bar did it in a good way. 

The marshmallows incorporate a chewy texture to the cookie, while the cornflake cereal imparts a great crunchy texture. Each cookie balanced a gooey and crispy texture, making every bite satisfying and perfect.

Although we hope for more marshmallows in the mix, we still have this cookie at the top of our list. But how do you reduce sugar in chocolate chip cookies?

1. Compost Cookie

Milk Bar Compost Cookies

This cookie combines butterscotch, pretzels, potato chips, coffee, chocolate chips, graham crackers, and oats in one perfect blend.

The undeniable tasty combination of salty and sweet ingredients put this Milk Bar Compost Cookie at the top of our list.

It has a golden brown appearance and a crunchy yet chewy texture. This cookie offering from Milk Bar is perfect for consumers who prefer salty snacks.

Besides, the coffee balances well against the sugar crash component of the ingredients.



How long are Milk Bar cookies good for?

Milk Bar cookies are good for five days at room temperature and up to a month in the freezer. You can reheat it for a few minutes at the right temperature before consuming it. 

What makes Milk Bar cookies different?

One thing that makes Milk Bar cookies different is Christina Tosi’s way of using nostalgic childhood recipes and giving them a twist for new consumers. Moreover, Tosi is also known for the aesthetic design of her Milk Bar bakery [2]

Are Milk Bar cookies soft or crunchy?

Milk Bar cookies are soft and crunchy. It depends on the cookie variety, but the inside is usually soft, while the outside is crunchy. 

Find out how you can make the cookies chewy and not cakey here.

Where to buy Milk Bar cookies?

You can buy Milk Bar cookies at any Milk Bar bake shop. You can also buy it online at their official site or local grocery stores like Target.

Final Verdict 

Milk Bar cookies are sweet snacks made using some recipes from our childhood, making them both irresistible and satisfying. Various cookie varieties are available in the market, each with distinct flavors and appearances.

Our team has chosen the Milk Bar Compost Cookie as our favorite variety because of its well-balanced flavors. 

Milk Bar cookies are available at their official website or other online shops. You can also buy them at local stores near you, like Target.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *