Clicky

Best Non-Toxic Cookie Sheets 

10 Best Non-Toxic Cookie Sheets & Bakeware (Updated)

Last Updated on April 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

Having a high-quality, professional standard baking sheet in your kitchen is vital, irrespective of whether you are a professional baker or just a baking enthusiast.

Along with the price and size, ensuring your baking sheets are non-toxic is crucial when baking. 

Since you want to avoid harmful chemicals mixing with your baked goods, here are the best non-toxic cookie sheets you should use. 

Top 10 Non-Toxic Cookie Sheets 

1. Gotham Steel Ceramic-Coated Non-Toxic Bakeware Set

Ceramic Cookie Sheet

Average Price: around $59 

Why We Like It: The Ti-Cerama non-stick coatings on Gotham Steel ceramic bakeware ensure that everything will slide off the pan without any issues. 

It’s dishwasher and oven safe and made with 100% PFOA-free materials. 

Gotham Steel is our best non-toxic bakeware for its excellent non-stick coating and even heat distribution while baking.

No toxic fumes, and we’re not worrying about cooking acidic foods as their non-toxic baking sheets are stain-resistant. 

No potentially toxic materials are used, so your food is safe. 

Pros: 

  • Stacks and stores easily
  • Ultra nonstick coating 
  • Even heating 
  • Low-priced
  • Ease of cleaning

Cons: 

  • Prone to scratches
  • Chips over time 

2. Caraway’s Ceramic Coated Aluminized Steel Bakeware Set

Set of Caraway's Ceramic

Average Price: around $245-$395

Why We Like It: This ceramic cookware uses a non-toxic chemical coating that won’t leach toxic materials into your food. 

Caraway’s non-toxic baking pans don’t contain any toxic chemicals like lead, PFAs, cadmium, etc. It’s oven-safe, and it can withstand temperatures up to 550-degree F. 

Its non-stick ceramic coating is not high maintenance, and less scrubbing is required during cleanup. 

Besides, it’s a commercial-grade aluminized steel, so there is no metallic taste in food. 

Pros: 

  • 5-piece or 11-piece option
  • Non-stick coating 
  • Includes easy storage organizer
  • Less CO2 production

Cons: 

  • Pricey
  • Not for extensive use  

3. USA Pan Non-Toxic Baking Sheet with Rack

Average Price: around $21-$69 

Why We Like It: The USA PAN non-toxic baking sheets with the rack are must-haves for any kitchen. 

We like their large baking sheet pan and baking rack, ideal for making delicious cookies, cakes, and other pastries.

These nonstick, non-toxic aluminum baking sheets come with a versatile rack with a steel cross-wire design that fits inside the pan keeping your baked food elevated as it cools.

It also helps keep food elevated while the oil or fat drips into the pan, ideal for making crispy bacon. 

You’re assured this bakeware won’t leach metal substances into your food. 

Pros: 

  • Limited lifetime warranty 
  • Unique corrugated surfaces 
  • Non-toxic silicone bakeware coating 
  • Warping-resistant 
  • FDA-approved (Food-safe)

Cons: 

  • Classic, old non-stick bakeware design
  • Hand washing required 

4. TeamFar Nickel-Free Non-Toxic Cookie Sheet Set

Average Price: around $20-$24 

Why We Like It: These stainless steel cookie sheets from TeamFar are one of the best non-toxic baking sheets for their nickel-free materials and non-toxic fumes while baking. 

You can choose from a set of 2 and 3 bakeware, which are all multipurpose–perfect for baking, roasting, and storing food.

No need for aluminum foil, parchment paper, or silicone baking mats as these baking dishes from TeamFar are highly non-stick. 

Also, the baking sheet comes in a 16-inch or 17.6-inch option.  

Pros: 

  • Multi Use
  • Rust-free
  • Easy clean
  • Budget-friendly 
  • Chemical-free

Cons: 

  • May warp at extreme temperatures
  • Scratches easily  

5. Great Jones Goods Baking Sheets With Fun Colors

Man Holding Great Jones Goods Baking Sheets With Fun Colors

Average Price: around $45-$85 

Why We Like It: Aluminum bakeware from Great Jones Goods has a cooking space ideal for baking and serving large food items, such as pizza. 

It’s easy to clean with soapy water and a soft sponge. 

These Great Jones non-toxic baking sheets come in four fun colors: raspberry, broccoli, mustard, and blueberry— all have a nonstick coating and size options. 

We’re using their half-sheet pan with a nonstick ceramic coating. It’s lightweight, easy to work with, and easy to clean. 

It’s available at 17.25×12.25×1 inches and 18.5×13.5×1 inches. 

Pros: 

  • Oven-safe
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Electric color options 
  • Two sheet size options 

Cons: 

  • Prone to chips and scratches
  • Needs to avoid metal utensils 

Read: What Causes My Baking Sheet To Warp In The Oven?

6. All-Clad Stainless Steel Bakeware

Baking Sheet with Cookie Dough

Average Price: around $99-$129

Why We Like It: The stainless steel baking sheets from All-Clad is a go-to option for hobbyists and professionals. 

It’s a commercial grade, resistant to warps and heat for up to 450-degree F. 

It’s easy to clean with warm water, gentle soap, and a soft sponge. It has two sets of options. 

The 10-piece set includes: 

  • Cookie sheet
  • Half sheet pan
  • Nonstick baking rack and cooling rack
  • 12-cup muffin pan
  • Square baking pan
  • 2 round cake pans
  • Rectangular baking pan
  • Quarter sheet pan
  • 1-pound loaf pan  

The 5-piece set includes: 

  • Cooling and baking rack
  • Cookie sheet
  • Loaf pan
  • Square pan
  • 12-cup muffin pan

Pros: 

  • Easy to clean 
  • Reasonably sized sheet pans 
  • Warp-resistant
  • Non-toxic baking pan 
  • Affordable 

Cons: 

  • Not for baking large batches
  • Heavy for its size  

7. CasaWare

Average Price: around $29-$37 

Why We Like It: CasaWare’s non-stick bake tools have a granite ceramic coating free of lead, PFOA, PFOS [1], and other harmful materials. 

It also has long-lasting scratch resistance and can withstand high temperatures up to 450-degree F. 

Besides, CasaWare has various pieces that can be used for different types of baking. 

The popular options are their 2-piece 15×10 inches baking sheets or the 3-piece with one 13×9 pan.  

Pros: 

  • Can withstand high temperatures
  • Aluminum-free
  • Very easy to clean
  • Granite ceramic coating 
  • Heavy duty and sturdy 

Cons: 

  • Prone to stains
  • Prone to chipping 

8. Rachael Ray Nonstick Bakeware Set with Grips

Baking Sheet Pan

Average Price: around $34

Why We Like It: The Rachael Ray nonstick bakeware set has three large non-stick cookie/muffin pans ideal for making sweet and savory treats. 

These non-toxic baking sheets are made from durable stainless steel with a long-lasting coating.

The large, medium, and small size baking sheets make it easy to do everything from making cookies to baking cakes.

Pros: 

  • Nice color, rich-looking
  • Size options 
  • Easy clean up
  • Sold and well-made
  • Non-stick, non-toxic baking sheets 

Cons: 

  • Needs an oil drizzle
  • Hand wash only

9. Ninja B39010 Foodi NeverStick Premium 10-Piece Bakeware Sheet Set

Average Price: around $179 

Why We Like It: These non-toxic baking sheets from Ninja Foodi have a durable and easy-to-clean coating that prevents food and wipes from getting stuck in holes. 

It’s oven safe and has a heavy gauge stainless steel body that resists warping and corrosion. The set includes a baking sheet, cookie sheet, muffin tins, loaf pan, etc. 

Pros: 

  • Comfortable grip
  • Safe materials
  • Can withstand 500-degree F
  • Heavy-duty aluminized steel 

Cons: 

  • One color only 
  • Unusually thick pans 

10. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Cookie Baking Sheets Set

Woman Holding Cookie Sheet

Average Price: around $22-$51

Why We Like It: One of the aluminum baking sheets safe for contact with food is Wilton’s Nonstick Bakeware as it’s non-toxic and no harmful substances are used. 

The set includes large and medium cookie sheets, which are versatile for making various types of baked food, such as cookies, cakes, and pies. 

“Baking cookies is comforting, and cookies are the sweetest little bit of comfort food. They are very bite-sized and personal.”

– Sandra Lee, American Dermatologist

You can choose from their 2-piece set to sets with a pie pan, pizza pan, cake pan, and more. 

Pros: 

  • Good for everyday use 
  • Quick cleanup
  • Baking sheet set options
  • Limited 10-year warranty 

Cons:

  • Hand washing recommended  
  • No color options

Check out these cookie storage containers to keep baked cookies fresh here.

Non Toxic Bakeware Materials 

Stainless Steel

A durable and high-quality material, stainless steel is great for baking. It does not react with food and emits no toxins [2].

Glass

Glass bakeware is non-leaching and non-reactive. Also, it’s generally heat-resistant. 

Stoneware

Stoneware allows even heating. It can maintain heat well while ensuring the food is free of toxins. 

Silicone

High temperatures can be safely handled using silicone, which is non-stick and can resist chemical contamination. Food-grade silicone does not pose a risk to food [3]. 

Non-Stick Ceramic

Non-reactive pure ceramic coatings are designed to keep food safe. They don’t contain chemical additives, so they won’t contaminate your food.

Cast Iron

A cast-iron skillet (or enameled cast iron) is a good alternative to non-stick cookware. It’s much more durable, so expect its longer lifespan.  

Read: Top 10 Cookie Airbrushing Kits

FAQs 

Can baking sheets be toxic? 

Yes, baking sheets can be toxic, especially when exposed to extensive temperatures. The materials used can break down, causing to release of toxic vapor. But does parchment paper contain PFAS?

What makes most baking sheets toxic?

What makes baking sheets toxic is the coating of Fluoropolymer, a Teflon, or polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) [4]. 

This material can break down in too much heat and release toxic vapor, as well as leach chemicals into your delicious food.

Are non-stick cookie sheets safe to use?

Non-stick cookie sheets aren’t safe, particularly in high heat, as they can release toxic vapor as your cook or bake. But it depends on the brand and material used. 

Are aluminum cookie sheets safe to use?

Aluminum cookie sheets can be safe to use compared to Teflon. However, untreated aluminum sheets are not recommended, especially when cooking salty or acidic foods, as aluminum can break down and release a foul metallic smell. 

But is it safe to put cookie sheets in the dishwasher?

What can I use instead of a baking sheet?

Instead of a baking sheet, you can use parchment or wax paper, foil, silicone mats, and cooking spray. But what are the best airbrush kits for cookies?

What is the safest bakeware for your health?

The safest bakeware for your health is cast-iron, stainless steel, ceramic, and glass. 

Is Pyrex cookie sheet non-toxic?

Yes. Pyrex cookie sheet is non-toxic and will not harm your food. They won’t absorb food stains, flavors, or odor.

Final Thoughts

You don’t want to put harmful toxins into your food when preparing dinner or baking treats. That’s why it’s important to use the best non-toxic baking materials.

Luckily, with all the best non-toxic baking sheets mentioned above, you have a variety of options to choose from. Now, you won’t have problems finding a style that suits your baking needs. 

References:

  1. https://www.p65warnings.ca.gov/fact-sheets/pfos-perfluorooctane-sulfonate-or-perfluorooctane-sulfonic-acid
  2. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/home-garden/what-is-food-grade-stainless-steel-and-its-benefits/articleshow/93297481.cms 
  3. https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/is-silicone-toxic 
  4. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28913736/ 
Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *