Clicky

Best Red Velvet Cake NYC 

15 Best Red Velvet Cake Options In NYC: Tasted & Ranked

Last Updated on April 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

The popularity of red velvet cake in New York City has skyrocketed thanks to its scrumptious flavor. The cake’s vivid red hue is a result of the acidic reaction between buttermilk, baking soda, and cocoa.

So, if you’re looking for a treat – be it for special occasions or to satisfy your craving – we’ve listed our favorite spots where you can find the best red velvet cake in NYC.

Top 15 (Must-Try) Red Velvet Cakes In NYC 

15. Red Velvet Cake from Buttercup Bake Shop

3 Layer Red Velvet Cake

Average Price: approx. $36 to $175, depending on the cake size 

Address: 167 Madison Ave New York, NY 

Why We Like It: This yellow cake has hints of cocoa with a deep red color. We like how this cake is frosted with cream cheese between the layers, which melts in the mouth. 

It’s rich and luscious. Simply delicious. 

14. Red Velvet Cake from Doc’s Cake Shop

Average Price: approx. $8 to $85, depending on the slice and cake size 

Address: 214 Bainbridge St., Brooklyn, NY 

Why We Like It: We like this red velvet cake from Doc’s cake shop. It’s not too sweet and not tangy. 

The cream cheese filling is not too thick and not too thin. It feels good on the mouth as it’s very soft. 

In fact, you can find simple yet delicious desserts and Southern-inspired cakes at this bakery, which draws people in.

13. Red Velvet Cake from Little Cupcake Bakeshop

Average Price: approx. $3.75 per cupcake

Address

  • 30 Prince Street, New York, NY
  • 9102 Third Avenue, Brooklyn, NY
  • 598 Vanderbilt Avenue, Brooklyn, NY

Why We Like It: This red velvet from Little Cupcake Bakeshop tastes traditional, with a cake made with cocoa and cream cheese icing. 

It’s vegan and sweet, like milk. It’s moist, and the frosting was thicker than usual, which we love. Besides, it has three stores within New York City, so it’s very accessible to the public. 

12. Red Velvet Cake from Molly’s Cupcakes 

Average Price: approx. $3 per cupcake 

Address: 228 Bleecker St, New York, NY 

Why We Like It: Molly’s red velvet is a must-try as it’s savory and delicious. It has the perfect sweetness–not too sweet but not bland. 

We like its moist texture, and you can choose from various frostings like buttercream, vanilla, chocolate, brown butter, and cream cheese. 

11. Red Velvet Cake from Empire Cake

Red Velvet Cake with White Frosting

Average Price: approx. $60 to $75, depending on the cake size 

Address: 112 Eight Ave. (Between 15th & 16th St.) New York, NY 

Why We Like It: We like how moist this red velvet cake is. It feels soft and fluffy on the mouth. The cream cheese frosting is thick; we were surprised it didn’t feel oily at all. 

We like the tanginess of its cream cheese, which complements the sweet flavor of the cake.

Apart from that, twinkies, coffee, and signature cakes are some of the creative and retro-style treats this bakery serves.

10. Red Velvet Cake from Martha’s Country Bakery

Average Price: approx. $9.95 per slice

Address: 70-28 Austin Street, Forest Hills, NY

Why We Like It: With many available cake variations from Martha’s County, we especially like their red velvet cake because it tastes flavorful and melts in the mouth. 

Martha’s red velvet cake is one of the best. It’s not too sweet, and the cake is moist and soft, which we really like. 

There are other offerings, too, including cinnamon Danish and hot chocolate.

9. Red Velvet Cake from The Cake Boss Cafe

Average Price: approx. $36

Address: 42nd Street and Eighth Avenue, NY

Why We Like It: The red velvet cake from The Cake Boss Cafe is elegantly delicious. Its classic cream cheese filling tastes a bit tangy, but it complements the sweet flavor of the cake. 

The cream cheese filling is delicious, and the moist layer is quite soft. We like how this classic Southern dessert incorporates the cream cheese frosting with chocolate shavings.

8. Red Velvet Cake from Betty Bakery 

Average Price: approx. $65 to $85, depending on the cake size 

Address: 448 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY

Why We Like It: This red velvet cake from the Betty Bakery is a lush take on the classic red velvet cake. Its cream cheese filling and frosting taste perfectly sweet and tangy. 

It looked simple on the outside, which made us a bit disappointed at first, considering the price of the cake. 

However, the inside is surprising, with three layers filled with a tasty filling, so we feel like taking a huge cake slice is worth it.

7. Red Velvet Cake from Eleni’s New York

Valentine Red Velvet Cake

Average Price: approx. $23 per pack

Address: 75 9th Ave. Chelsea Market New York City, NY

Why We Like It: We like the red velvet minis from Eleni’s. It’s one of the favorites for its tastiness. The cream cheese filling isn’t tangy but mildly sweet. 

So, if you want to avoid too sweet treats but want to enjoy a dessert – try this cake from Eleni’s.

We had the opportunity to try their different frostings, such as chocolate and vanilla. They both taste good and delightful. 

But we still prefer cream cheese over the red velvet cake. Find out how you can frost a cake without tearing it here.

6. Red Velvet Cake from Billy’s Bakery

Average Price: approx. $70 to $150, depending on the cake size

Address: 184 9th Avenue B/W 21st and 22nd New York, NY

Why We Like It: This red velvet cake from Billy’s Bakery has a mild chocolate flavor with a vivid red color. It oozes with a cream cheese frosting for a Southern classic. 

What we like about this cake is it can be customized. You can choose a color for the inscription and the garnish you like. 

5. Red Velvet Cake from Lady M Cake Boutique

Average Price: approx. $110 to 119, depending on the cake size

Address: 498 Red Apple Ct Central Valley, NY

Why We Like It: This red velvet from Lady M is a classic winter treat. It has three layers of luscious sponge cake with a rich cream cheese filling, which we like. Indeed, a perfect indulgence.

4. Red Velvet Cake from Sweet Revenge

Average Price: approx. $3.50 per serving

Address: 95 Horatio St, New York, NY

Why We Like It: This red velvet from Sweet Revenge has a dark chocolate flavor filled with creamy raspberry mousse and topped with white chocolate frosting. 

“If there’s one cake that screams ‘celebration,’ it’s got to be red velvet cake.”

– Nigella Lawson, Food Writer

It’s unique from the cakes on this list due to the chocolate notes. This is a must-try if you like the red velvet feel with chocolate. 

3. Red Velvet Cake from Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery

Close Up Shot of Red Velvet Cake

Average Price: approx. $2.75 per serving 

Address: 126 Rivington Street, NYC

Why We Like It: The red velvet cake from Sugar Sweet Sunshine has two flavors: Sexy (with the moose) and Sassy (with chocolate almond buttercream). 

Both are sweet and delicious, but we prefer the Sexy flavor, as we find the Sassy one too buttery on the mouth. 

Actually, the Red velvet cake is their signature creation. It’s really creamy and luscious, with vanilla buttercream, making it a great little cake for any occasion.

2. Red Velvet Cake from Amy’s Bread

Average Price: approx. $5.95 per slice 

Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY

Why We Like It: Amy’s red velvet cake is sweet and perfect for kids and adults. If you’re like us that want sweets, our go-to choice is Amy’s Bread. 

It’s really sweet, but the hint of tang is noticeably tasty. The sponge cake is very soft and a bit moist – good mouthfeel. 

1. Red Velvet Cake from Cake Man Raven

Slicing Red Velvet Cake

Average Price: approx. $6 per serving 

Address: 201 W 135th St, New York

Why We Like It: This red velvet cake from Cake Man Raven is made using buttermilk, vinegar, cocoa powder, and a small amount of red food coloring. 

This is our favorite red velvet treat for its moist texture and vibrant red color. We also like its cream cheese frosting with nuts.

Read:

FAQs 

Are different kinds of Red Velvet Cake available for delivery in NYC?

Yes, different kinds of red velvet cake are available for delivery in NYC. There are 970 menu items to choose from. 

What’s the best red velvet cake in Westchester, NYC?

The best red velvet cake in Westchester, NYC, is from Nothing Bundt Cakes. It’s soft and moist, and it melts in the mouth. 

Its cream cheese [1] filling has the perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess. But what are the different flavors of a birthday cake?

On A Final Note

If you’re in NYC craving a sweet treat, try the red velvet cake [2] within the state. From the Buttercup Bakeshop to the Cake Man Raven, there’s sure to be a red velvet cake that will satisfy your tastebuds. 

But if you’ll ask the most recommended one — no doubt, it’s the Cake Man Raven’s red velvet cake. Every bite is a pleasure and will leave you wanting more.  

References:

  1. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/cream-cheese 
  2. https://www.southernliving.com/food/desserts/cakes/southern-red-velvet-cake 
Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *