Can You Replace Vegetable Oil With Coconut Oil In Brownies

Can You Replace Vegetable Oil with Coconut Oil in Brownies?

Last Updated on June 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

Each time I bake brownies, memories of cozy afternoons in the kitchen flood back, experimenting with different ingredients. One time, I ran into a pickle, running out of a key ingredient and needing to improvise a substitute.

The result? A surprising tropical twist that had everyone curious. It’s funny how sometimes straying from the usual can lead to the most delightful discoveries in baking.

If you’re looking to add a hint of adventure to your treats, sometimes the simplest swaps can make all the difference. Find out if you can replace vegetable oil with coconut oil in brownies.

Dive in, and let your taste buds guide the way!

Can You Swap Vegetable Oil With Coconut Oil For Brownies?

Brownies Bar

Yes. You can replace vegetable oil with coconut oil in brownies. Just ensure it’s melted and used in equal measure.

“The most classic French dessert around the holidays is the Christmas log, with butter cream. Two flavors. Chocolate and coconut. My first job in the kitchen when I was a boy was to make these Christmas logs.”

– Alain Ducasse, Monegasque Chef

This swap introduces a slight coconut flavor and can add a richer texture to your brownies. Remember to check the final consistency, as coconut oil’s texture differs slightly from vegetable oil.

But is it okay to use canola oil in baking brownies?

Why Use Coconut Oil?

  1. Richer Texture: Coconut oil [1] can give brownies a creamy, dense consistency, making them feel even more indulgent.
  2. Flavor Enhancement: It imparts a subtle tropical, coconutty note, adding a unique twist to the traditional brownie.
  3. Health Aspects: Coconut oil contains medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs), some believe offer health benefits.
  4. Solidifies When Cooled: This property can make brownies slightly firmer, providing a chewy texture that many desire.
  5. Natural Ingredient: For those aiming for more natural or less processed ingredients in their baking, coconut oil is a great choice.
  6. Lactose-Free: A good option for those with lactose intolerance if the recipe calls for butter.
  7. High Smoke Point: Coconut oil has a high smoke point, reducing the risk of breaking down and producing harmful compounds during baking.
  8. Versatility: Works well with additional flavors, such as nuts or fruits, enhancing the overall brownie profile.

Does Coconut Oil Affect The Brownie’s Consistency?

Yes, coconut oil can influence the consistency of brownies [2]. When used to replace other fats, coconut oil, which solidifies at cooler temperatures, can lead to a slightly firmer and denser brownie. 

Its unique composition offers a creamy texture when melted and, once baked, often results in a rich, moist interior with a chewy edge. 

The end product is a delightful balance of softness and chewiness, making coconut oil a fascinating choice for brownie enthusiasts seeking a distinct texture.

Find out if you can use canola oil for cake mix here.

How Does The Flavor Change When Using Coconut Oil?

A tropical, coconutty undertone is introduced to the flavor profile when using coconut oil in brownies.

Especially if one opts for virgin coconut oil, the brownies take on a delicate coconut essence that melds with a rich chocolatey base. 

This infusion can elevate the taste, offering a unique twist to the traditional brownie. However, refined coconut oil can be used for those who prefer a more neutral flavor, as it carries less coconut taste while still providing the textural benefits.

What’s The Replacement Ratio?

Woman Holding Bottle of Oil in a Supermarket

For brownies and most other baking recipes, the replacement ratio when substituting vegetable oil with coconut oil is typically 1:1. 

“In the dance of baking, swapping vegetable oil for coconut oil is like changing the music’s rhythm; familiar steps with an exotic twist, elevating brownies to a tropical delight.”

– Leonelli Bakery

If a recipe calls for 1 cup of vegetable oil, you would use 1 cup of melted coconut oil as its substitute. Ensure the coconut oil is liquid when measuring to get an accurate amount.

Are There Health Benefits To This Switch?

  1. Medium-Chain Triglycerides (MCTs): Coconut oil is rich in MCTs, which are digested more rapidly than long-chain triglycerides in other fats. Some studies suggest they boost metabolism and increase energy expenditure.
  2. Lauric Acid: Coconut oil contains lauric acid with antimicrobial and antiviral properties, potentially supporting immune health.
  3. Reduction in Harmful Trans Fats: Unlike some hydrogenated vegetable oils, pure coconut oil doesn’t contain trans fats, which are associated with numerous health risks.
  4. Cholesterol: There’s ongoing debate about the effects of coconut oil on cholesterol. While it may raise LDL (bad) cholesterol, it also boosts HDL (good) cholesterol.
  5. Brain Health: MCTs in coconut oil produce ketones when metabolized, which can serve as an alternative energy source for the brain. This has sparked interest in the potential neurological benefits of coconut oil.
  6. Satiety: Some studies indicate that the fats in coconut oil can increase feelings of fullness, which might help manage weight.
  7. Stable at High Temperatures: Coconut oil has a higher smoke point than other oils, making it less likely to break down and produce harmful compounds during baking.
  8. Natural and Unprocessed: Virgin coconut oil is minimally processed, retaining more of its natural properties.

Also Read: Is It Okay To Grease A Pan Using Coconut Oil?


Will coconut oil change the baking time of brownies?

Not significantly. However, it’s always a good practice to start checking a few minutes before the usual time.

Coconut oil might make the edges crisp up a bit faster, so keep an eye out for those telltale signs of done-ness: pulling away from the edges and a set center.

Find out if it’s okay to use canola oil for waffles here.

Can I use coconut oil in any brownie mix or recipe?

Yes, coconut oil is a versatile substitute. Whether using a boxed mix or a homemade recipe, coconut oil can seamlessly replace vegetable oil.

However, always consider the flavor profile, as coconut oil might introduce a light coconut essence, especially if you’re using the virgin variety.

Key Takeaways

Replacing vegetable oil with coconut oil introduces a subtle tropical essence and offers potential health benefits. 

While coconut oil does lead to a slightly different consistency, the outcome is a moist and decadent treat that many find irresistible. 

Balancing taste, texture, and health considerations, switching to coconut oil in brownies is a flavorful and intriguing experiment worth trying for any avid baker.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *