How Do You Make Allspice

How Do You Make Allspice at Home? DIY Spice Blend Recipe

Last Updated on April 23, 2024 by Lori Walker

Do you always have allspice in your spice cabinet like I do? Its uniqueness truly sets it apart. Do you know the process of creating homemade allspice?

Allspice comes from a particular tree’s berries. These berries are picked, dried, and turned into the spice used in our kitchens. 

Let’s dive deeper into how allspice is made and how to use it in your recipes.

Steps On How To Make Allspice

Hand Full of Allspice
  1. Find the Right Tree: Allspice comes from the dried berries of the Pimenta dioica tree. If you have access, pick fresh berries directly from the tree.
  2. Pick the Berries: Choose fully mature berries that need to be opened. They should be green and firm.
  3. Wash Them: Rinse the picked berries under clean, running water.
  4. Dry the Berries: Spread the washed berries on a clean cloth or tray. Let them sun-dry for several days until they turn brown.
  5. Roast Them (Optional): For a deeper flavor, roast the dried berries in a pan over low heat for a few minutes.
  6. Grind Them: Once thoroughly dried (and optionally roasted), use a spice grinder or mortar and pestle to grind the berries into a fine powder.
  7. Store: Keep your homemade allspice in an airtight container. Store in a cool, dry place away from sunlight to maintain its flavor.

“Even just a few spices or ethnic condiments that you can keep in your pantry can turn your mundane dishes into a culinary masterpiece.”

– Marcus Samuelsson, Chef

Where Does Allspice Come From?

Allspice [1] comes from the dried berries of the Pimenta dioica tree, which is native to the warm climates of Central America, specifically regions of Mexico, Belize, Guatemala, and parts of the Caribbean like Jamaica. 

Often referred to as “Jamaican pepper” or “new spice,” this unique spice has a flavor that combines cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg.

Once picked and dried, the berries are ground into the aromatic allspice powder we commonly use in cooking. But what’s an Allspice McCormick?

Can I Make Allspice At Home?

While you can’t grow the allspice tree in many colder climates, you can create a homemade substitute for allspice by mixing equal cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg. 

This blend will be different from real allspice, but it can come close in flavor and is a handy alternative when you can’t find allspice readily available. 

Remember that allspice have a unique taste, so this homemade mix will offer a slightly different flavor profile in your recipes.

Why Is It Called “Allspice”?

Hand Holding Allspice

The name “allspice” might make you think it’s a mixture of many spices, but it’s not! It’s called “allspice” because its flavor is reminiscent of a combination of several spices. 

When the English encountered it in the 1600s, they found that it had a distinct taste that mimicked the flavors of cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg. 

“From the warmth of a tree to the heart of a dish, allspice is nature’s blend in a single berry’s wish.”

– Leonelli Bakery

So, they cleverly named it “allspice” to capture its unique and versatile flavor, even though it comes from a single type of berry.

How Can I Use Allspice In Cooking?

  1. Baking: Add a pinch of allspice to your pie fillings, cookies, or cakes for a warm and aromatic flavor.
  2. Savory Dishes: Use allspice in savory recipes like stews, soups, and meat rubs to give them a depth of flavor.
  3. Marinades: Include allspice for chicken, pork, or beef to infuse them with a unique taste.
  4. Pickling: Add a dash of allspice to pickling solutions for a distinctive and slightly spicy kick.
  5. Mulled Beverages: Enhance the flavor of mulled wine or cider by incorporating allspice into the mix.
  6. Spice Blends: Create your spice blends for grilling or roasting by combining allspice with other herbs and spices.
  7. Caribbean Cuisine: Explore Caribbean cuisine [2] where allspice, especially in jerk seasoning, is a star ingredient.
  8. Homemade Syrups: Make your flavored syrups for pancakes or waffles by infusing them with allspice.

Also Read: How Long Will Nutmeg Last?


Can I use allspice as a direct substitute for cinnamon in recipes? 

While allspice shares some flavor notes with cinnamon, it has a more complex taste.

You can use allspice as a substitute, but it will change the flavor profile of your dish. Start with a smaller amount, taste, and adjust to find the right balance.

Find out how many grams of ground cinnamon are in one cinnamon stick here.

Is there a difference between ground allspice and whole allspice berries in recipes? 

Ground allspice and whole berries have distinct uses. Ground allspice is ideal for even distribution of flavor in baking and cooking.

Whole berries are often used in pickling and simmering dishes, where they can be removed before serving.

Both have the same flavor but offer different textures and culinary applications. But how many allspice berries are there in a teaspoon?

In Conclusion 

Making allspice is a straightforward process that begins with the dried berries of the allspice tree. These berries are sun-dried, ground into a fine powder, and stored in a cool, dry place. 

While you can create a homemade blend that mimics allspice’s flavor, true allspice comes from a single source—the allspice berry. 

Its unique taste, which combines hints of cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg, makes it a versatile and cherished spice in kitchens worldwide. 

Allspice adds a warm and aromatic flavor that elevates culinary creations in sweet desserts or savory dishes.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *