How Long Can Sweet Potato Pie Last In The Fridge

How Long Can Sweet Potato Pie Last in the Fridge? Answered

Last Updated on June 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

People **love** sweet potato pie for its warm, cozy, and incredibly sweet taste.

You might have recently indulged in a delicious slice of this comforting treat or plan to bake one yourself. But how long can sweet potato pie last in the fridge?

Today, I’ll share the shelf life of sweet potato pie in the refrigerator, assuring you can savor every bite of this delightful treat. Read on. 

How Long Is Sweet Potato Pie Good For In The Refrigerator?

Close Up Image of a Sweet Potato Pie

Sweet potato pie can stay good for about five days when properly stored. After that, it might start to lose its flavor and texture. 

To keep your sweet potato pie delicious, store it in the refrigerator, tightly covered.

“So the pie isn’t perfect? Cut it into wedges. Stay in control, and never panic.” 

Martha Stewart, American Businesswoman and Writer

So, remember to enjoy your leftover pie within this timeframe to ensure it’s at its best when you take that next delicious bite.

But how can you store sweet potato pie?

Can Sweet Potato Pie Still Be Good After Sitting For A Week?

Yes, sweet potato will still be good after a week. It can be refrigerated for up to one week and still taste fresh. 

To achieve this, ensure it’s tightly covered to prevent drying out and absorbing any unpleasant odors from the fridge [1]. 

Your sweet potato pie should retain its delightful flavor and texture even after a week. 

However, be vigilant for any signs of spoilage to ensure your continued enjoyment of this delectable dessert.

Find out how you can keep pumpkin pie from cracking here.

How Long Can Sweet Potato Pie Be Left Out After Baking?

After baking a delicious sweet potato pie, knowing how long it will safely sit out is essential. Simply put, leave it out for no more than two hours. 

Sweet potato pie recipes often contain milk and eggs, perishable ingredients requiring prompt refrigeration. 

If your freshly baked pie is left unrefrigerated for longer than two hours, it’s safer to discard it to avoid the risk of harmful bacteria growth. 

“Your sweet potato pie’s stay in the fridge is its time to shine, offering deliciousness that lingers for about 5 days.”

Leonelli Bakery

So, remember to enjoy your pie promptly or store it in the fridge to keep it delicious and safe.

Check out these brands that make the best chicken pot pie here.

How Do I Know If Sweet Potato Pie Has Gone Bad?

Slice of Sweet Potato Pie on a Plate

Detecting if your sweet potato pie has gone bad is crucial. You can do this by inspecting the pie for noticeable color, smell, or texture changes. 

When you identify an unusual or unpleasant odor or see mold forming on the surface, it’s a clear-cut sign that the pie has spoiled and must be disposed of promptly.

Additionally, watch out for any excessive sogginess in the filling or an overly hard crust, which can also indicate spoilage. 

By being attentive to these warnings, you can secure the safety and deliciousness of your sweet potato pie.

What Happens If Sweet Potato Pie Is Left Out Overnight?

Leaving sweet potato pie out overnight can lead to unpleasant consequences. The pie’s moist filling creates an environment that promotes mold growth when stored at room temperature. 

Mold can develop rapidly, making the pie unsafe to eat. Mold alters the taste and texture of the pie and can pose health risks if consumed. 

To ensure the safety and freshness of your sweet potato pie, it’s crucial to refrigerate it within two hours of baking. 

Read: What Is The Ideal Thickness For Pie Crust?


What caused the crack in the center of my sweet potato pie?

If you’ve noticed a crack in the center of your sweet potato pie, the most likely cause is overbaking. 

To avert this, promptly remove your pie from the oven when a toothpick inserted into the center indicates it’s done.

What could be causing my sweet potato pie to stay soft?

If your sweet potato pie stays soft, it’s likely due to underbaking. Underbaking can prevent the sweet potato filling from fully setting. 

Make sure to bake your pie for the recommended time for a firm and delightful texture.

Is sweet potato pie meant to be eaten cold?

Sweet potato pie can be enjoyed at room temperature or chilled, depending on your preference. 

There is no strict rule; it’s entirely up to you how you’d like to savor this delicious dessert.

What causes white spots to appear on my sweet potato pie?

The white spots you’re observing on your sweet potato pie are caused by liquid starch [2].

Sweet potatoes often release this mixture of sugar and starch when cut into, and it’s completely normal. 

This liquid starch is not exclusive to sweet potatoes and is typically found in various starchy foods.

Can sweet potatoes spoil if stored in the refrigerator?

Sweet potatoes cannot be spoiled if it’s stored in the refrigerator. 

They can last several weeks to a month when stored at room temperature, but they can extend their freshness to three months in the refrigerator. 

How will you tell if a sweet potato has gone bad?

To determine if a sweet potato has gone bad, look for signs such as soft spots, a rotten smell, or a mysterious oozing liquid. 

If you observe any of these indicators, it’s advisable to discard the sweet potato to avoid consuming spoiled or potentially unsafe food.

In Summary

The pie is one of the delectable desserts that can be enjoyed while ensuring its freshness and safety.

Sweet potato pie can last for about five days when stored in the fridge with proper covering. 

Leaving it out at room temperature for more than two hours can result in mold growth and spoilage, making it unfit to eat. 

Recognizing the signs of spoilage, such as changes in color, smell, or texture, is essential to ensure you’re consuming a safe and delicious treat. 

So, refrigeration and vigilance are key to savoring sweet potato pie to its fullest potential.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *