How Long To Bake Cake Pops In Silicone Mold

How Long to Bake Cake Pops in Silicone Mold: Perfect Guide

Last Updated on June 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

Cake pops are a hit among both newbie and pro bakers. **Using a silicone mold** is the secret to getting them **just right every time**. It makes sure they’re always the same shape and size.

However, one common question arises: How long should you bake cake pops in a silicone mold? 

From my experience, striking the right balance is crucial to achieving a moist center and a perfect outer crust. Let’s dive into the specifics.

How Long Should I Bake Cake Pops In A Silicone Mold?

Cake Pops Silicone Mold

When using a silicone mold, baking cake pops at 350°F (175°C) for 15-20 minutes is recommended. However, exact times can vary based on the specific recipe and oven. 

Baking cake pops [1] in a silicone mold typically require a precise balance of temperature and time to achieve that perfect, moist center with a slightly crispy exterior. 

“I tried to bake a cake for my mother’s birthday – it took me four hours. It was terrible, and I cried for three days.”

– Rachael Ray, American Professional Cook

To ensure they are baked to perfection, it’s crucial to check for doneness with a toothpick, which should come out mostly clean with a few crumbs attached.

Why Is The Baking Time Different For Silicone Molds Compared To Other Methods?

Silicone molds have distinct properties that differentiate them from traditional metal or glass bakeware. 

Being a flexible and non-conductive material, silicone distributes heat more evenly and retains it longer, which can lead to reduced baking times. 

Furthermore, its non-stick nature facilitates the more accessible release of baked goods without much residual heat, minimizing the chances of over-baking post-removal. 

Hence, when using silicone molds, it’s essential to adjust baking times and keep a close eye to prevent overcooking.

Find out if you can put a silicone mold in the oven here.

How Can I Ensure That My Cake Pops Are Fully Baked?

  1. The Toothpick Test:
    • Method: After the minimum baking time has passed, insert a clean toothpick or skewer into the center of one of the cake pops.
    • Result: If it comes out clean or with just a few crumbs, your cake pops are likely done. If there’s wet batter, they need more time.
  2. Touch Test:
    • Method: Gently press the surface of a cake pop with your finger.
    • Result: If the cake pop springs back lightly, it’s done. If it leaves an indentation, consider extending the baking time.
  3. Observation:
    • Method: Look at the color and surface of the cake pops.
    • Result: Fully baked cake pops should have a consistent golden-brown color. Any uneven or very pale sections might indicate the need for more baking.
  4. Size and Rise:
    • Method: Compare the size of the baked cake pops to their size before baking.
    • Result: Cake pops should rise slightly when they’re baking. They might need more time or very little if they have not risen.
  5. Smell:
    • Method: The aromatic scent of baked goods fills the kitchen when they’re nearing doneness.
    • Result: A fragrant, sweet smell usually indicates that your cake pops are getting close to being fully baked.
  6. Consistency Check:
    • Method: Cut open a test cake pop after removing it from the oven.
    • Result: The inside should be fluffy and consistent without any doughy sections. They might need further baking if the center appears wet or too dense.

Does The Size Of The Silicone Mold Affect Baking Time?

Cake Pops on a Silicone Molder

Yes. The size of the silicone mold [2] plays a pivotal role in determining the baking time. Larger molds or those with deeper cavities require a longer baking duration to ensure that the center of the cake pops is cooked thoroughly. 

Conversely, smaller or shallower molds heat up and bake the batter more rapidly, leading to reduced baking times. 

Thus, it’s essential to adjust your baking time based on the specific dimensions of your silicone mold to achieve perfectly baked cake pops. 

Always refer to the manufacturer’s guidelines or conduct periodic checks during baking to ensure doneness.

Should I Let The Cake Pops Cool In The Mold?

Yes, letting the cake pops cool in the silicone mold briefly after baking is advisable. 

Allowing them to cool for 10-15 minutes will make removing them easier without causing breakage or deformation. Silicone molds are naturally non-stick, but the cake pops’ structure is fragile when hot. 

“In the dance of desserts, cake pops twirl to perfection when time and silicone molds harmoniously align.”

– Leonelli Bakery

Once slightly cooled, the cake pops will become more resilient and can be transferred to a cooling rack to finish cooling entirely without retaining too much moisture, which can occur if left in the mold for an extended period.

Related Post: Does A Silicone Cupcake Liner Need To Be Greased?


Can I use a regular cake mix for cake pops in silicone molds? 

Yes. Most cake pop recipes allow for the use of your favorite cake mix.

When using a silicone mold, ensure that the batter’s consistency is appropriate for the mold, and remember to adjust the baking time according to the mold’s size and the specific recipe.

But is it okay to freeze cake pops after dipping?

Do I need to grease a silicone mold before adding the cake batter? 

One of the advantages of silicone molds is their non-stick quality. However, you can lightly spray the mold with cooking spray or brush it with minimal butter for an even easier release.

This step is only sometimes necessary but can be helpful, especially for intricate mold designs.

Key Takeaways

Baking cake pops in a silicone mold offers a convenient and efficient method for creating these delightful treats. 

The baking time can vary based on the specific recipe, the size of the mold, and individual oven variances. 

Typically, it ranges from 15-25 minutes. Monitoring them closely, especially during the first attempt, ensures optimal results. 

Silicone molds can distribute heat evenly, ensuring a consistent bake. Once baked, allowing the cake pops to cool slightly in the mold can make them easier to handle. 

Whether you’re a novice baker or an expert, silicone molds can simplify the cake pop-making process, delivering delicious results every time.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *