How Often Does Crumbl Repeat Cookie Flavors

How Often Does Crumbl Repeat Cookie Flavors? Explained

Last Updated on March 23, 2024 by Lori Walker

Crumbl Cookies is known for their ever-changing menu, which sets them apart from others.

But how often does Crumbl repeat cookie flavors? Let’s journey into the cookie jar to understand the delicious strategy Crumbl uses to keep their offerings as fresh as their baked goods.

How Frequently Does Crumbl Repeat Its Cookie Flavors?

Gingersnap Cookies on a Plate

While Crumbl rotates its unique cookie flavors every week, a single specific flavor might take anywhere from 2 weeks to 3 months to reappear on the menu. 

“I have to stop eating so much grilled cheese and chocolate chip cookies and start working on everything!”

– Melanie Martinez, American Singer-Songwriter

Their enormous assortment of over 120 delicious recipes allows a diverse rotation schedule.

So, while you can anticipate the reappearance of a beloved flavor, exactly when that will occur adds a delightful unpredictability to your Crumbl experience.

But when will Crumbl release new cookie flavors?

Are There Any Seasonal Cookie Flavors At Crumbl?

Yes. Crumble brings out the joy of the seasons with its unique and compelling seasonal cookie flavors. 

These seasonal delights typically coincide with holidays or events, such as pumpkin spice cookies in the autumn, peppermint cookies during the winter holidays, or lemon-infused cookies in the spring. 

These unique flavors add a festive touch to the Crumbl lineup and allow customers to enjoy the taste of the seasons in a lovely way.

Read: Are There Dairy-Free Cookies At Crumbl?

Popular Cookie Flavors That Have Been Repeated

  1. Milk Chocolate Chip: A classic and fan favorite, the milk chocolate chip cookie [1] is a staple flavor that Crumbl often repeats due to high demand. This cookie is loaded with gooey milk chocolate chips and baked to perfection.
  2. Chilled Sugar Cookie: A chilled sugar cookie that’s soft, sweet, and delicious. It is one of Crumbl’s most loved cookies and is often reintroduced due to its popularity.
  3. Sea Salt Toffee: This flavor perfectly balances sweet and salty. The rich, buttery toffee cookie is sprinkled with coarse sea salt, making it a repeat contender on Crumbl’s rotating menu.
  4. Cookies and Cream: A true nostalgic delight, this cookie is stuffed and topped with Oreo pieces, delivering a familiar taste of childhood that Crumbl fans often look forward to.
  5. Raspberry Cheesecake: With its perfect blend of fruity, sweet, and tangy flavors, the Raspberry Cheesecake cookie is another crowd-pleaser with multiple appearances on Crumbl’s menu.

Find out if Crumbl cookies have nuts here.

Can Customers Request A Repeat Of Their Favorite Cookie Flavor?

Box of Crumbl Cookies

Absolutely! Crumbl loves hearing feedback from its loyal customers. If there is a specific cookie flavor that you adore and want to see back on the menu, you can certainly request it. 

“In the world of Crumbl cookies, repetition is the spice of life, serving up familiar flavors that echo sweet memories, all the while teasing your taste buds with the thrill of the new and unexpected.”

– Leonelli Bakery

Contact them via social media channels, customer service email, or in-store.

While they can’t guarantee the return of every requested flavor due to their rotating menu model, they take customer feedback seriously. 

It’s always worth expressing your cookie cravings because your favorite might reappear. Find out how you can order mini Crumbl cookies here.

Are There Any Permanent Cookie Flavors At Crumbl?

Yes, while Crumbl is known for its rotating menu of unique cookie flavors, they do maintain a couple of permanent offerings that have become customer favorites:

  1. Milk Chocolate Chip: A classic flavor that everyone loves. This cookie is loaded with milk chocolate chips and is baked to be soft in the middle with a slightly crispy exterior.
  2. Chilled Sugar Cookie: This is Crumbl’s unique take on a classic sugar cookie [2]. It’s soft, sweet, and topped with their signature almond-flavored frosting.

These cookies are consistently available, providing a dependable, delicious option alongside the exciting new flavors that appear each week.

Related Post: Best Cumbl Cookie Flavors You Should Try


How does Crumbl decide on flavors?

Crumbl’s decision on flavors is based on a combination of factors. First and foremost, they aim to provide a diverse and exciting selection of cookies that vary from week to week.

The decision process involves a creative team that explores different ideas, looking at current food trends, seasonal ingredients, and customer feedback.

But how can you keep Crumbl cookies fresh?

Are Crumbl Cookies undercooked?

Crumbl Cookies are not undercooked but intentionally baked to be exceptionally soft and slightly gooey in the middle, a characteristic many customers love.

This might give the impression that they are undercooked, but they are, in fact, thoroughly baked according to food safety standards.

Final Thoughts

Crumbl’s cycle of cookie flavors is as dynamic as it is delicious.

The company ensures a rotational scheme that allows popular flavors to return every two weeks to three months, maintaining a balance between novelty and familiarity for their customers. 

Seasonal favorites make a comeback every year, adding a sense of anticipation and joy to the various holiday seasons. 

While certain permanent fixtures exist in their cookie lineup, most of Crumbl’s cookie flavors delightfully surprise customers each week. 

This approach, built on customer feedback and creative experimentation, makes every Crumbl visit a unique and exciting cookie adventure.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *