How To Make French Toast Without Vanilla

How to Make French Toast Without Vanilla: Tasty Alternatives

Last Updated on April 23, 2024 by Lori Walker

When the desire for a flavorful breakfast hits, many opt for French toast. But, don’t fret if you lack vanilla extract in your kitchen. I was able to whip up a scrumptious French toast without using it.

Let me show you how to make this classic breakfast favorite using simple ingredients you already have in your kitchen.

Whether you’re out of vanilla extract or prefer a different flavor profile, mastering French toast without vanilla is a handy skill to satisfy your morning cravings. 

5 Ways To Make French Toast Without Vanilla

French Toast with Slice of Strawberry on the Side

1. Cinnamon Spice

Consider the Cinnamon Spice [1] version for a delectable twist on French toast without vanilla. Instead of vanilla extract, add a pinch of ground cinnamon to your egg and milk mixture. 

Whisk it together, dip your bread slices into the aromatic blend, and cook them to golden perfection.

“I have a doughnut every morning. The same kind, from a street cart. Vanilla frosted with sprinkles on one half, weirdly. How hard is it to sprinkle the whole thing?”

– Allison Williams, American Sports Commentator

The warm, earthy notes of cinnamon infuse your French toast with a cozy, comforting flavor that’s delightful and reminiscent of your favorite spice-laden pastries. 

It’s a simple, satisfying alternative that may become your new breakfast favorite.

2. Maple Madness

Indulge in the sweet charm of Maple Madness French toast, a delightful alternative when vanilla extract is unavailable. Instead of vanilla, blend your eggs and milk with pure maple syrup.

This substitution infuses your bread slices with a rich, sugary goodness to satisfy your morning cravings. 

Dip your bread into the mixture, cook until golden brown, and savor the essence of maple syrup paired perfectly with the comforting warmth of French toast. It’s a delicious twist on a classic breakfast favorite.

Find out the difference between Texas toast and garlic bread here.

3. Almond Elegance

For a touch of elegance in your French toast, turn to Almond Elegance when vanilla extract is not on hand. Instead of vanilla, add a drop of almond extract to your egg and milk mixture. 

Whisk it together, dip your bread slices into this fragrant blend, and cook them to golden perfection. The subtle nutty notes of almond extract will elevate your French toast, giving it a sophisticated and slightly sweet flavor profile. 

It’s a delightful twist that adds a touch of luxury to your breakfast table. But why do people love bread so much?

4. Orange Zest

Plate of French Toast

Add a burst of citrusy freshness to your French toast by trying the Orange Zest variation, perfect when you’re out of the vanilla extract. 

Instead of vanilla, whisk together eggs, milk, and freshly grated orange zest. Immerse your bread slices in this vibrant mixture, and cook them until they turn a golden hue. 

The zesty aroma and tangy notes of orange zest will awaken your taste buds, offering a bright, invigorating, refreshing, and satisfying flavor. This citrus-infused French toast is a delightful way to start your day with sunshine.

5. Coconut Dream

Indulge in a tropical escape with Coconut [2] Dream French toast, a delicious choice when vanilla extract is absent. Instead of vanilla, whisk eggs and milk with a hint of coconut extract. 

“French toast is a canvas of flavors, and even without vanilla, you can paint a delicious masterpiece using the palette of your pantry.”

– Leonelli Bakery

Soak your bread slices in this exotic blend and cook them to golden perfection. The gentle, creamy essence of coconut extract will transport your taste buds to a serene beachside paradise, adding a delightful twist to your French toast. 

It’s a dreamy breakfast experience that’s as satisfying as it is unique.

Also Read:


Can I combine different flavorings, such as cinnamon and maple syrup, to make French toast without vanilla?

Yes. Combining various flavorings can yield fantastic results.

For instance, you can use a pinch of cinnamon and a drizzle of maple syrup in your egg and milk mixture to create a layered flavor profile that’s sweet and spicy.

Are there any non-liquid substitutes for vanilla extract when making French toast?

Yes, you can use ingredients like almond butter, peanut butter, or even a dash of your favorite liqueur, like amaretto or Grand Marnier, to infuse your French toast with distinctive flavors.

Remember to adjust the quantity according to your preference for flavor strength.

In Conclusion

Making French toast without vanilla is possible and an opportunity to explore a wide array of exciting flavor alternatives. 

Whether you opt for spices, extracts, or other creative additions, the key is to experiment and tailor your French toast to your unique taste preferences. 

With some culinary ingenuity, you can craft a delightful breakfast experience that’s just as satisfying, if not more, than traditional vanilla-infused French toast. 

So, the next time you’re out of vanilla extract, embrace the culinary adventure and savor the diverse flavors of your homemade French toast.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *