How To Store Sweet Potato Pie

How to Store Sweet Potato Pie & Ensure Lasting Freshness

Last Updated on June 22, 2024 by Lori Walker

If you come across a sweet potato pie, its irresistible aroma and delightful flavor might lead to its rapid consumption.

But what do you do when you can’t finish the whole pie in one sitting? I’ve got some simple tips for storing sweet potato pie to ensure it stays fresh and tasty.

So, keep reading to ensure your homemade sweet potato pie stays delicious for days.

How Can You Store A Sweet Potato Pie?

Homemade Sweet Potato Pie

Follow these simple steps to keep your sweet potato pie fresh and delectable. Once your pie has achieved room temperature, carefully seal it with storage wrap or aluminum foil.

Then, place it in the refrigerator. Ensure it’s well covered to prevent moisture or odors from affecting the pie. 

“We must have a pie. Stress cannot exist in the presence of a pie.”

David Mamet, American Playwright and Filmmaker

Stored this way, your sweet potato pie will stay at its best for three to four days, allowing you to savor its deliciousness whenever you desire [1]. 

Do You Need to Keep Sweet Potato Pie In The Fridge?

Yes, you should store sweet potato pie in the fridge. Here’s why: sweet potato pies typically contain milk and eggs [2], which make them similar to baked custard pies. 

If you leave these ingredients at room temperature for too long, they can spoil. 

To keep your sweet potato pie safe to eat and taste great, refrigerate it promptly after it has cooled to room temperature. 

This simple step ensures your sweet potato pie remains fresh, delicious, and free from potential spoilage. 

How Long Should Sweet Potato Pie Cool Before Going In The Fridge?

Ensure it cools down entirely before refrigerating to get the most out of your sweet potato pie. The ideal cooling period for sweet potato pie is two to three hours.

You can tell it’s ready when you touch the bottom of the pie pan when there is no warmth.

The cooling step before refrigeration is critical because it prevents condensation from developing inside the storage wrap or aluminum foil, which could result in a crust becoming soggy.

So, exercise patience and let your pie cool down completely before stashing it in the fridge to ensure it stays irresistibly delicious.

How Long Can Sweet Potato Pie Be Stored In The Refrigerator?

You can store sweet potato pie in the refrigerator for about five days and still enjoy its deliciousness. To keep it fresh, make sure it’s tightly covered. 

The fridge acts as a shield, preserving your sweet potato pie by slowing spoilage. 

It’s important to note that after this five-day mark, the pie’s quality may decline, so it’s best to enjoy it within this time frame. 

Whether it’s a homemade treat or leftovers from a special occasion, you can savor the sweet delight of sweet potato pie for several days as long as you store it correctly.

Find out the recommended thickness of a pie crust here.

Is It Safe To Leave Sweet Potato Pie Unrefrigerated Overnight?

Freshly Baked Sweet Potato Pie

Yes, leaving sweet potato pie at room temperature for a short period is generally safe. 

You can keep it unrefrigerated for up to two days without any significant risk of spoilage or foodborne illness. 

This is because sweet potato pie containing dairy and eggs is often baked at a high temperature, which helps kill harmful bacteria. 

But after the two-day mark, transferring the pie to the refrigerator is safer to maintain its freshness and prevent any potential bacterial growth. 

How Should Sweet Potato Pie Be Stored Overnight?

If you plan to store your sweet potato pie overnight, here’s what to do: loosely cover the pie with aluminum foil before placing it in the refrigerator. 

“Sweet potato pie – a dessert so divine, it’s worth the wait for that first heavenly bite.”

Leonelli Bakery

By taking this simple action, you can guarantee the continued freshness of your pie and safeguard it against fridge odors.

The foil helps maintain the pie’s moisture and prevents the crust from becoming too soggy. 

Using this approach, you can refrigerate your sweet potato pie for up to three days without compromising its delectable flavor.

So, whether for a special occasion or a midnight snack, your sweet potato pie will be ready to enjoy whenever you please.

Related Post: Helpful Tips To Make Pie Crust Without A Food Processor


What happens if you refrigerate a pie before letting it cool?

If you refrigerate a pie before letting it cool, condensation can form inside, leading to a soggy crust. 

Allowing it to cool first, for about two to three hours, helps preserve the pie’s texture and prevents excess moisture from ruining it.

Is sweet potato pie better served hot or cold?

Sweet potato pie is traditionally enjoyed slightly chilled or at room temperature. Serving it this way allows its flavors to develop fully, making for a more delicious and enjoyable treat. 

But how does a Rhubarb pie taste?

Can a warm pie be safely placed in the fridge?

Yes, putting a warm pie in the fridge is safe, but there’s a right way to do it. Allow the pie to cool on the countertop, then refrigerate it to complete cooling and keep it cold. 

Ensure your fridge maintains a temperature of 41°F or colder, except during serving.

Wrapping Up

Baking sweet potato pie is a delightful experience, but knowing how to store it properly ensures you can savor its goodness for days.

First, storing sweet potato pie in the fridge is crucial because it contains ingredients like milk and eggs, similar to a baked custard pie. This helps prevent spoilage.

After baking, allow your pie to cool completely for about two to three hours before refrigeration. This ensures no moisture collects inside, keeping the crust crispy.

Lastly, when storing it overnight, loosely cover the pie with aluminum foil before refrigerating for up to three days.

Enjoy the deliciousness of sweet potato pie and keep it fresh and safe to eat by following these straightforward steps.


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *