Clicky

Smeg Mixer vs Kitchenaid

Smeg Mixer vs KitchenAid: What’s the Difference? (2023)

Last Updated on July 8, 2023 by Lori Walker

Smeg and KitchenAid are two iconic brands that have been at the forefront of culinary innovation.

These two major brands offer top-quality stand mixers that elevate your baking experience, but which is better?

As an experienced cook, I’ve relied on these popular stand mixers, so I’ve compiled a detailed comparison of Smeg Mixer vs KitchenAid to help you choose which is better. Read on.

Smeg Mixer & KitchenAid Differences

White Smeg Stand Mixer

Smeg is known for its domestic appliances and kitchenware, but KitchenAid is famous for its premium kitchen appliances.

KitchenAid has more stand mixer models, accessories, and sizes than Smeg. You can attach a flat beater, wire whip, pouring shield, beater blade, and pasta rollers on the mixer head.

Also, the KitchenAid models are more affordable and versatile than Smeg for a casual baker or seasoned cook.

However, Smeg has built a reputation for its design-forward approach and commitment to quality craftsmanship.

Also, they offer powerful machines, which are ideal for heavier ingredients but can be more expensive.

KitchenAid is an American brand that has graced many kitchens since 1919 [1], while Smeg is an Italian brand established in 1948 [2].

KitchenAid & Smeg Comparison

Smeg MixerKitchenAid
OriginItalyUSA
Material QualitySturdy construction, durable materialsSolid build, high-quality components
AffordabilityGenerally higher price rangeOffers a range of models with varying prices
Overall Cooking PerformanceExcellent mixing and blending capabilitiesRenowned for consistent and powerful performance
SelectionsLimited range of models and colorsWide variety of models, colors, and attachments
CompatibilityMay have limited compatibility with non-Smeg accessoriesExtensive range of compatible accessories and attachments

Key Differences

Location & History

Established in Italy in 1948, the Smeg brand has become synonymous with stylish and innovative kitchen appliances.

The brand has become a significant player in major appliances like washing machines, refrigerators, wine coolers, and small appliances like stand mixers, toasters, and food processors.

On the other hand, the KitchenAid brand originated in the USA and was established in 1919.

It was formerly from Hobart Manufacturing Company and is now a subsidiary of the Whirlpool Corporation. KitchenAid is one of the country’s major kitchen appliance brands.

Power

Smeg mixers feature more powerful stand mixers than Kitchenaid. The brand ensures efficient mixing and can handle thick dough and heavy ingredients.

The robust power of Smeg mixers makes them ideal for demanding tasks in the kitchen.

On the other hand, Kitchenaid stand mixers are also powerful and very efficient, especially when mixing smaller ingredients.

But if you want more powerful Kitchenaid stand mixers, expect to spend more money. But what’s the distinction between KitchenAid Classic and Deluxe stand mixers?

Smeg vs KitchenAid Design

Smeg mixers are renowned for their retro-inspired, 50’s style design, adding a touch of nostalgia and elegance to the kitchen.

Their stylish aesthetics make them a standout addition to any countertop, so they get the upper hand in this category.

On the contrary, KitchenAid mixers feature a classic design that has remained iconic over the years. Classic KitchenAid mixers have timeless appeal and add sophistication to kitchen decors.

Check out the differences between a hand mixer and an immersion blender here.

Accessories

KitchenAid mixers are accompanied by a standard set of attachments, including a mixing bowl, dough hook, beater blade, flat beater, pouring shield, and aluminum and steel wires whisk.

What I like more about KitchenAid is the compatibility of their attachments in other models like Classic, Deluxe, and Kitchenaid Artisan Mixers.

“Where style meets performance, Smeg Mixer and KitchenAid redefine culinary excellence.”

– Leonelli Bakery

Additionally, KitchenAid has a wide array of optional attachments, such as a pasta roller, meat grinder, food grinder, and ice cream maker, allowing users to customize their mixer based on their culinary needs.

Smeg mixers include necessary attachments, such as a mixing bowl, plastic bowl cover, dough hook, and wire whisk. However, the specific attachments included may vary depending on the model.

Both KitchenAid and Smeg stand mixers offer an attachment hub compatible with various culinary techniques.

Also Read: Which KitchenAid Mixer Attachment Is Best For Baking A Cake?

Size & Weight

KitchenAid mixers come in different sizes, ranging from compact countertop models to more extensive, professional-grade mixers, accommodating various batch sizes.

Smeg mixers offer limited sizes, catering to different kitchen spaces and user preferences. They offer both compact and larger models to suit different needs. The weight of Smeg mixers may vary depending on the specific model.

Speed Control

Smeg mixers and Kitchenaid have similar 10-speed settings. They are easy to operate because you only need to move the speed control switch forward and backward.

The only difference I observed is that Smeg mixers have a smooth start feature that allows you to start at the lowest speed, even if the control knob is higher.

Durability & Construction

Based on my observation, the Smeg model has more durable mixers because they are mostly made from sturdy steel and aluminum.

Smeg stand mixers are known for their attention to detail and use of high-quality materials, including stainless steel bowls and durable components.

KitchenAid stand mixers are known for their solid construction and robust materials, ensuring longevity and reliable performance.

Bowl Capacity

Kitchenaid has a broader selection of bowl capacities than Smeg.

If you want to make smaller batches of delicious cookie dough, pizza dough, and whip egg whites, Kitchenaid offers a 3-5 quart bowl capacity.

On the other hand, Smeg offers a bigger bowl capacity, with the smallest at 5 quarts; Kitchenaid has multiple sizes that can cater to bigger batches of ingredients.

Number of Models & Color Variety

KitchenAid boasts an extensive lineup of stand mixer models (bowl-lift and tilt head), offering classic colors and finishes to match any kitchen decor or personal style [3].

Smeg offers a range of stand mixer models with different features and capacities, allowing users to choose the one that best suits their needs.

However, Smeg mixers maintain a consistent retro-inspired aesthetic. Find out the differences between Ankarsrum and KitchenAid stand mixers here.

Price Point

Smeg mixers are positioned in the higher price range, reflecting their superior design and quality. The retro-inspired aesthetics and superior performance of Smeg mixers justify their higher price point.

KitchenAid mixers are available at various prices, offering options for different budgets. Their models range from entry-level to high-end professional mixers, allowing users to choose based on their budget and specific needs.

Do Smeg Mixer & KitchenAid Share Similarities?

Woman Holding Kitchenaid Stand Mixer

Both major brands offer stand mixers that deliver reliable performance and durability.

They offer a variety of necessary attachments and optional accessories to enhance versatility in the kitchen.

Additionally, both KitchenAid and Smeg provide options for different bowl capacities, tilt-head, or bowl lift functions, allowing users to choose based on their batch size requirements.

“The more you know, the more you can create. There’s no end to imagination in the kitchen.”

– Julia Child, American Cook

However, it’s the differences in design, price range, and specific features that set them apart from each other.

Read: How Long Will KitchenAid Mixers Last?

Examining KitchenAid & Smeg Stand Mixers Model

50’s Style SMEG Stand Mixer 

Key Features

The 50’s Style SMEG Stand Mixer boasts a retro design with a chrome-plated base and various vibrant color options.

It offers a powerful 800W motor, a 5 quarts bowl, 10-speed settings, and a planetary mixing action.

Pros 

  • A retro-inspired design
  • Powerful motor
  • Stainless steel bowl ensures durability and easy cleaning.
  • Precise speed control

Cons

  • Higher price point
  • Limited color

KitchenAid Artisan 5 Qt Mixer

Key Features

The KitchenAid Artisan 5 Qt Mixer is renowned for its performance and versatility. It features a powerful 325W motor, a 5-quart bowl, 10-speed settings, and a unique planetary mixing action.

Pros 

  • Classic design
  • Powerful motor and planetary mixing action
  • 5-quart stainless steel bowl accommodates different batch sizes.
  • Wide range of color options for customization.

Cons

  • Some attachments may need to be purchased separately.
  • heavier

FAQs

Are any attachments not included with the KitchenAid included with the Smeg mixer?

No, both Smeg and KitchenAid mixers have necessary attachments such as a mixing bowl, beater, and wire whisk.

However, additional attachments may vary depending on the model and are sold separately. Find the distinction between Jenn Air and KitchenAid stand mixers here.

Can the attachments from the KitchenAid mixer be used on the Smeg mixer?

No, the attachments designed for KitchenAid mixers are incompatible with Smeg mixers. Each brand has its attachment system and accessories.

Find out the steps for removing a bowl from the KitchenAid mixer here.

Which mixer is easier to use, the Smeg or the KitchenAid?

The KitchenAid mixer is easier to use than the Smeg mixer. KitchenAid mixers have a user-friendly interface with intuitive controls, making adjusting speeds and switching between attachments easy.

Additionally, KitchenAid offers a broader range of compatible accessories and attachments, enhancing its versatility and ease of use in various cooking tasks.

But is KitchenAid Artisan better than Ultra Power stand mixers?

Which is a more beginner-friendly stand mixer, Smeg or KitchenAid? 

The KitchenAid stand mixer is more beginner-friendly compared to the Smeg mixer. KitchenAid mixers offer a user-friendly interface with precise controls and straightforward operation.

They also come with various helpful attachments and accessories that cater to beginners, such as a dough hook to knead doughs of any kind or a wire whip for whipped cream.

Final Verdict

After careful consideration and testing, KitchenAid emerges as the Kitchenaid vs Smeg face-off winner.

Its versatility, comprehensive options, beginner-friendly design, and affordability make it a reliable choice.

However, the Smeg mixer shouldn’t be overlooked, particularly for those seeking power and robustness.

Smeg and KitchenAid have their merits, but KitchenAid takes the lead with its user-friendly interface and extensive range of attachments.

Whether you prioritize versatility and accessibility or power and style, both mixers have the potential to elevate your culinary experiences.

Please choose the one that aligns with your specific needs and preferences, and let it become your kitchen companion on your gastronomy adventures [4].

References:

  1. https://www.cnet.com/pictures/a-visual-history-of-kitchenaid-stand-mixers/ 
  2. https://www.independent.co.uk/property/interiors/the-secret-history-of-the-smeg-fridge-2155837.html 
  3. https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/reviewedcom/2018/06/04/kitchenaids-popular-stand-mixer-is-at-its-lowest-price-in-6-rare-colors/35685063/ 
  4. https://www.britannica.com/topic/gastronomy
Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *