Butterscotch Vs. Butter Rum

Butterscotch vs Butter Rum: What’s the Difference?

Last Updated on June 21, 2024 by Lori Walker

Both butterscotch and butter rum are super popular flavors in desserts and drinks. These rich, creamy tastes are great for cozying up on chilly days or wrapping up a meal with a sweet treat.

Let me check the similarities and differences between butterscotch and butter rum to help you choose the perfect flavor for your next dessert or drink.

Main Differences Between Butterscotch & Butter Rum

pouring butterscotch on a bowl
  1. Flavor: Butterscotch [1] has a sweet, caramel-like flavor due to the combination of brown sugar, butter, and vanilla. In contrast, butter rum has a warm, spiced flavor due to the combination of rum and spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.
  2. Sweetness: Butterscotch is generally sweeter than butter rum due to its high sugar content. Butter rum has a more balanced sweetness due to the added spices.
  3. Alcohol content: Butter rum contains rum, which gives it a distinct flavor and a small amount of alcohol. Butterscotch does not contain any alcohol.
  4. Versatility: Butterscotch is a more versatile flavor that can be used in various desserts and drinks. It pairs well with many ingredients and can add richness to many recipes. Butter rum, while delicious, has a more specific flavor profile that is best suited for certain types of desserts and drinks.
  5. Texture: Butterscotch has a smooth, creamy texture similar to caramel. Butter rum has a slightly thicker texture due to the addition of spices.

Which Flavor Is Better For Desserts? 

Butterscotch’s sweet, caramel-like flavor pairs well with various desserts, such as cakes, pies, and ice cream. Its smooth, creamy texture can add richness and depth to many desserts. 

On the other hand, butter rum’s warm, spiced flavor is best suited for desserts with a similar warm, spiced flavor, such as apple pies or gingerbread cakes.

The rum and spice combination can add complexity and depth to these types of desserts. 

Which Flavor Is Better For Drinks, Butter Rum or Butterscotch?

Butterscotch Syrup on a Jar

When choosing between butterscotch and butter rum for drinks, the decision can be influenced by the occasion and personal preference. Butter rum is famous for warm, comforting drinks such as hot buttered rum or butter rum coffee. 

“With the notable exceptions of rum drinks, black beans, fat brown cigars, the smiles of pretty girls, hot yellow sunlight, and fat men with guitars and bongos playing mambos, rumbas, and boleros late into the night, nothing in Cuba comes easily.”

– Jonathan Miles, American Author

Its warm, spiced flavor is perfect for sipping on a cold winter night. Butterscotch, on the other hand, is an excellent flavor for adding to coffee or hot chocolate to give it a rich, sweet taste.

Its caramel-like flavor and smooth texture make it a perfect addition to many hot drinks. 

Find out the key distinction between Pralines & Cream and Butter Pecan here.

Which Flavor Is Healthier?

Regarding the health benefits of butterscotch and butter rum, neither flavor is particularly healthy due to the high sugar [2] and calorie content. 

However, if one chose the two, butterscotch would be considered the healthier option as it contains no alcohol. 

“Butterscotch and Butter Rum, a tantalizing tango of flavors where velvety sweetness embraces the warmth of spirits. In each sip or bite, the essence of indulgence unfurls, a dance between caramel dreams and the cozy firelight of rum.

Leonelli Bakery

Butter rum contains rum, which can add extra calories and adversely affect health in excess. 

Additionally, both flavors should be consumed in moderation as they can contribute to weight gain and other health issues when consumed in excess.

Also Read: 10 Recipes For Baked Goods That Use A Lot of Butter


Does rum candy have alcohol?

It depends on the specific type of rum candy. Some rum candies are made with actual rum and do contain alcohol. These candies are typically labeled as containing alcohol and may not be suitable for children or individuals who avoid alcohol. 

Other rum candies are made with rum flavoring or extract and do not contain actual alcohol. It is essential to check the ingredients and labeling of any candy to determine whether it contains alcohol.

What flavor is closest to butterscotch?

The flavor that is closest to butterscotch is caramel. Butterscotch and caramel have similar sweet and rich flavors, often used interchangeably in desserts. 

Other flavors similar to butterscotch include toffee and dulce de leche, also made from caramelized sugar and butter.

But what’s the taste of butter pecan?

In Conclusion

Butterscotch and butter rum is delicious flavors that offer a rich buttery taste. While they share some similarities, such as their creamy, indulgent taste, they also have distinct differences in flavor and texture. 

Butterscotch is a sweet, caramel-like flavor made with brown sugar, butter, and vanilla, while butter rum has a warm, spiced flavor made with rum and spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. 

When it comes to choosing between the two flavors, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and the occasion. 


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *