Last Updated on July 18, 2023 by Lori Walker
For home cooks who like to bake bread in large batches, you’d need the help of stand mixers to aid in mixing and kneading dough.
In the world of mixers, one name stands out – KitchenAid. However, not all KitchenAid stand mixers are made equal, which can be evidenced by their large number of selections.
So before you start mixing that bread dough, we researched, tested, and created an in-depth guide to help you decide which between KitchenAid Artisan vs Ultra Power is better.
Comparing KitchenAid Ultra Power & Artisan
The small difference between the two models may be challenging to spot since both brands have an advantage over one another.
While the KitchenAid attachments present in these two models are the same, we noticed that the wattage of the Artisan is 325, while the Ultra Power uses only 300.
It’s also noticeable that the KitchenAid Ultra Power stand mixer has a 4.5-quart capacity, while the Artisan series has 5 quarts.
Price-wise, the Ultra model costs around $329.99 to $399.99, while the latter costs $349.99 to $449.99. But how does KitchenAid differ from Smeg Mixer?
|KitchenAid Artisan||KitchenAid Ultra Power|
|Origin||United States, released on February 2002.||United States, released on October 2007.|
|Material Quality||Durable metal construction with a bowl made of stainless steel and dishwasher safe.||Made of stainless steel and features a tilt-head mixer for easier access to the beater and bowl.|
|Affordability||Costs around $349.99 to $449.99.||Costs around $329.99 to $399.99.|
|Overall Cooking Performance||Excellent performance and versatility||Good performance in basic tasks|
|Compatibility||Wide range of attachments||Limited compatibility with attachments|
The Artisan KitchenAid mixer has a 5-quart mixing bowl capacity which can help you in baking larger quantities of cakes, bread, and other pastries.
On the contrary, the Ultra Power series stand mixer has a 4.5-quart capacity which is 0.5 quarts smaller than the Kitchen Aid Artisan.
The Ultra Power has a 300-watt motor vs Artisan, which is at 325 watts. If you’re mixing cookie dough or cakes in your bowl, the 25-watt discrepancy won’t make much difference.
However, you’ll see the difference if you’re mixing dough (bread) in your bowl.
This Ultra Power KitchenAid mixer has 0.40 horsepower, and this 300-watt item, when used for about 5 minutes daily, will consume only 25 watt hours.
On the other hand, the Artisan 325-watt stand mixer can handle 2 loaves of bread (compared to 1 by the Ultra Power), provided it’s not daily.
The Artisan has a bowl with a handle and is made of stainless steel, while the Ultra Power’s bowl does not come with a handle.
When bowl type is considered, the Artisan model takes the spot as it is easier to control when you are pouring content or mixing since you can carry the bowl conveniently.
“It’s a reliable and proven machine that can help the home baker/cook up their game significantly. This mixer is in constant use at my restaurant.”– Kenny Hoshino, Head Pastry Chef for Gray’s Hall
The bowl of the Artisan model also has more capacity (5 quarts) compared to the Ultra Power model, with only 4 1/2 half quarts.
This might seem small, but if you run out of cookies for your little girl’s party or pastries at your next family gathering, you’ll definitely appreciate this 0.5 additional capacity.
Regarding accessories, the Ultra Power stand mixer model comes with a flat beater, a C dough hook, and a 6-wire whip to help you thoroughly mix the ingredients in the bowl.
It also boasts a 10-speed slide control, ranging from a rapid whipping to a very slow stirring process.
“Artisan crafts precision, Ultra Power delivers relentless culinary mastery.”– Leonelli Bakery
Meanwhile, the Artisan stand mixer has a nylon-coated flat beater and dough hook, a six-wire whisk, and a pouring shield for baking bread or pastries.
This can help you create almost anything – from your own pasta, ice cream, veggie noodles, and burgers . It can also mix your dough more thoroughly compared to doing it manually.
This model’s pouring shield ensures that all contents are safely transferred to another container without messing.
The Artisan has a durable metal construction with a bowl made of stainless steel and is dishwasher safe . It also comes in 20 color choices – perfect for those with a themed kitchen.
Like the Artisan, the Ultra Power is made of stainless steel and has a tilting head feature for easier access to the beater and bowl.
Both brands can mix dough for a single loaf, but the Artisan can take on an additional batch of dough (provided it’s not daily), making it more durable than the Ultra.
Usability & Versatility
The Ultra Power is better for mixing small volumes, while the extra capacity of the latter can help you in baking 2 loaves of bread.
It has also been proven more versatile and recognized as a best-selling stand mixer . But what’s the difference between Jenn Air and KitchenAid stand mixers?
The Ultra Power costs around $329.99 to $399.99 on average, while the Artisan costs $349.99 to $449.99 on average, depending on the retailer.
This leads to a not-so-huge difference of $20 – $40.
- How Does KitchenAid Classic Differ From Deluxe Stand Mixers?
- How Does All-Clad Differ From Cuisinart Cookware?
- How Does Ankarsrum Differ From KitchenAid Stand Mixers?
- How Does KitchenAid 600 Differ From 6000 Stand Mixers?
KitchenAid Artisan & Ultra Power Similarities
Like every KitchenAid Classic, Ultra and Artisan fall under Whirlpool Corporation’s KitchenAid brand .
Other brands falling under the Whirlpool umbrella, one of the leading home appliance companies, include Jenn-Air, Amana, Maytag, and Consu.
Compared to the other models, the Artisan and Ultra have a 10-speed motor that can mix heavy loads and make your life easier.
These are the same mixers, so they come with the same KitchenAid attachments like the stainless bowl, a flat beater, a dough hook, and a whip.
The Artisan wins by a point in this category, thanks to its pouring shield, which the Ultra doesn’t have.
Examining KitchenAid Ultra Power & Artisan
KitchenAid Ultra Power
- 300-watt power
- 4 1/2 quarts stainless steel bowl capacity
- It comes with a tilt-head lift
- It can be used to mix light to medium quantity ingredients
- Compatible with most KitchenAid stand mixer attachments
- More affordable and budget-friendly
- Since its head can be tilted, it’s easier to wash after use
- Some accessories aren’t dishwasher safe
- The bowl doesn’t come with a handle
- It doesn’t have a pouring shield
- The locking pins tend to disengage
- 325-watt power
- 5 quarts stainless bowl size
- It comes with a tilt-head lift
- With more power and bigger capacity, it can be used to mix dough for 2 loaves of bread
- It comes with a pouring shield
- The bowl comes with a handle
- Accessories can be put in the dishwasher
- Easy to clean after using, thanks to its head that can be easily tilted
- One of the best-selling stand mixers of all time
- Can’t be used for breadmaking frequently
- The locking pins have a chance of disengaging
- The bowl might require several washes before becoming thoroughly clean
Are there any attachments included with the KitchenAid Artisan mixer that are not included with the Ultra Power?
Yes, there are attachments present in the former that the latter doesn’t have. The Artisan comes with a pouring shield, and its bowl has a handle – features not found in the latter.
Which mixer is more suitable for heavy-duty mixing tasks, the Kitchen Aid Artisan or Ultra Power?
The Artisan is a better choice if you’re looking to mix many ingredients and prepare a large batch of pastries, pasta, or even ice cream.
This is best used if you’re looking to host a party or are preparing large amounts of pastries for your small business.
Additionally, the Ultra Power has 59 touchpoints, the Ultra Power Plus has 67, and the Artisan has a whopping 69.
Can the attachments from the KitchenAid Artisan mixer be used on the Ultra Power mixer?
Yes, the attachments from the KitchenAid Artisan mixer be used on the Ultra Power mixer. Some certain models can have their attachments interchanged, including the Artisan and the Ultra, since they are both from the KitchenAid brand.
Which mixer is more compact, the KitchenAid Artisan or Ultra Power?
The Ultra Power is more compact vs Artisan, and you can use this in mixing small to medium-sized ingredient quantities.
This difference is due to the fact that it only uses 300 watts and comes with a slightly smaller 4 1/2 quarts bowl.
In the Ultra Power vs Artisan battle, the clear winner is the Artisan. Thanks to its 5-quart bowl capacity, you can now prepare more pastries without having to wait in between batches.
Its tilt head feature is also very useful, especially during cleaning.
If you’re after a more budget-friendly stand mixer and are just looking to prepare a little something for you and your family, then you’re all set with the Ultra Power.
- How Long Can Whipped Frosting Sit Out? Storage Guide (2023) - September 13, 2023
- Does Cream Cheese Icing Have to Be Refrigerated? 2023 Guide - September 13, 2023
- Difference Between White and Yellow Cake Mix: Solved (2023) - September 12, 2023