Best Lenny and Larry Cookie

10 Best Lenny & Larry Cookie Flavors: Tasted & Ranked

Last Updated on March 23, 2024 by Lori Walker

If you are looking for a tasty cookie that meets higher health standards, choosing Lenny & Larry is a great choice.

Aside from being “protein-rich” cookies, Lenny & Larry offers a variety of delicious flavors, making them one of the in-demand healthy treats today.  

To have a clear glimpse of the flavors you should choose, we ranked the best Lenny and Larry cookie treats that will satisfy your tastebuds. 

Top 10 Lenny & Larry Cookies To Satisfy Your Tastebuds 

10. Lemon Poppy Seed

Hand Holding Lenny & Larry Cookie Lemon Poppy Seed

This is a soft and chewy cookie with a lemon flavor, and it’s topped with a bit of sweet and crunchy poppy seeds.  

Not all appreciate this flavor, which is underrated, but it has great potential. This might be a good alternative if you’re not a fan of chocolate. 

We’re not expecting much from this cookie, but its bold lemon flavor and the combination of the crunchy and sweet poppy seeds won us over.

9. Peanut Butter

Pack of Lenny & Larry Cookie Peanut Butter on a Wooden Table

Compared to the Birthday Cake, this Peanut Butter cookie is a better choice, though it comes off dry. Despite the dryness, we like this cookie for its tastiness and crunchiness.  

If you are a massive fan of peanut butter, you better try this one. But if you’re the type looking for a bit more delicious, proceed with the following cookies.

8. Oatmeal Raisin

Hand Holding a Pack of Lenny & Larry Cookie Oatmeal Raisin

Although it’s not our first choice when it comes to protein-filled cookies, this Oatmeal 

Raisin is one of our favorites. It’s a classic style of cookies made with oats and sweet raisins for a bit of flavor.

This creamy and breakfast-inspired Lenny & Larry cookie is one of the ideal go-to morning protein treats. We like the combination of the cookie’s flavor and texture.

7. Salted Caramel

Man Holding Lenny & Larry Cookie Salted Caramel

The Salted Caramel is an excellent option for a protein cookie, too, but how we wish to taste more “salted caramel” here. Regardless, we super love this flavor. 

“A balanced diet is a cookie in each hand.”

— Barbara Johnson, American Literary Critic and Translator

You can enjoy the salted caramel flavor without worrying about your health. This cookie is moist and chewy, infused with caramel chips and sea salt. It is a wonderful treat. 

6. Double Chocolate

Pack of Lenny & Larry Cookie Double Chocolate

This is the cookie that is specifically made for people who love chocolates. Double Chocolate is a combo of their chocolate chip cookie and a chocolate cookie base. 

Though it is sweet and very chocolatey, it has a considerable amount of protein. Trust us when we say it’s a great treat for any chocolate lover. 

This fantastic combination will leave you wanting more. But what are the best milk bar cookies to try?

5. Choc-O-Mint

Lenny & Larry Cookie Choc-O-Mint

The combination of mint and chocolate is so enticing that we considered this one of the top five among Lenny & Larry’s protein cookies.  

Basically, this Choc-O-Mint is a chocolate cookie with a bit of mint all throughout, which gives this cookie a bit of spice, making this one unique among other flavors. 

Besides, the burst of mint in this cookie is like transporting us to childhood.  

4. Snickerdoodle

Close Up Shot of Lenny & Larry Cookie Snickerdoodle Pack

This flavor is excellent, with a nice texture and a cinnamon taste. We find this cookie very easy to crumble and is really flavorful. 

We always love the taste of snickerdoodles, especially their cinnamon-filled flavor. It is tasty and sweet, making it a perfect afternoon or midnight snack. 

3. Chocolate Chip

Hands Holding Pack of Lenny & Larry Cookie Chocolate Chip

This Chocolate Chip cookie is precisely what you would expect it to be. It comes with a good portion of chocolate chips, and the ratio of chips to cookies is relatively good. 

If you’re a fan of chocolate chip cookies and would like a protein version, we highly recommend this one.

This classic flavor from Lenny & Larry’s was executed well, and the cookie is very chewy.

Read: Guide To Reduce Sugar In Chocolate Chip Cookies

2. Pumpkin Spice

Woman Holding Lenny & Larry Cookie Pumpkin Spice

This one is a seasonal flavor that Lenny & Larry create, which we can’t find outside of fall. 

Among Lenny & Larry’s cookies, Pumpkin Spice is a sought-after flavor next to White Chocolate Macadamia. 

This is flavorsome and delicious–perfect every morning, post-workout, and as an afternoon snack. If only this cookie were available all year round, this might be the top favorite flavor.  

Check out these delicious store-bought lemon cookies here.

1. White Chocolate Macadamia 

Close Up Shot of Lenny & Larry Cookie White Chocolate Macadamia 

This White Chocolate Macadamia is perfect for anyone who likes to break away from regular chocolate. 

The basic cookie base has been enhanced with a creamy white chocolate coating and a crunchy macadamia [1] nut layer. 

These cookies are an excellent treat for any occasion and are available in retailers nationwide. 

If you are looking for an excellent vegan cookie, you should try this—delicious and healthy. 


Are Lenny & Larry’s cookies tasty?

Yes. Lenny and Larry’s cookies are definitely tasty. They’re flavorsome and chewy and, of course, healthy. 

How long do Lenny & Larry’s cookies last?

Lenny and Larry cookies may last six months up to a year, depending on how you store them. You can refrigerate it or at least store it at room temperature. 

Are Lenny & Larry cookies good for bodybuilding?

Lenny and Larry cookies can be good for bodybuilding as long you eat the right amount. It has good fiber, carbs, and protein—perfect post-workout. 

What is the deal about the Lenny & Larry cookie lawsuit? 

The Lenny and Larry lawsuit is about the misrepresentation of the nutritional value of their “Complete Cookie,” reaching the point that they need to pay a $5 million settlement to solve the allegations [2]. 

How healthy are Lenny & Larry’s cookies?

Lenny and Larry are cookies are healthy because their cookies are made from all-natural ingredients. The protein is plant-based, and the fiber comes from the chicory root. It is a vegan cookie. 


Among Lenny and Larry’s cookies, our top favorite is the White Chocolate Macadamia. It’s creamy, crunchy, and unique from the typical chocolate cookies. 

But beyond that, there are more tasty flavors to choose from–from Lemon Poppy Seed to Choc-O-Mint to Pumpkin Spice. These cookies aren’t just delicious but healthy as well. So, which is your favorite? 


Lori Walker

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *